English Name Homophily Premium
Observational StudyReview
Disparities in interview callback rates between majority-group and ethnic minority applicants are traditionally modeled as a discount or penalty imposed on minority groups due to perceived deficits. However, empirical findings across non-Anglo groups demonstrate that discrimination operates as an exclusive premium awarded to traditional Anglo-Saxon names rather than specific group-targeted hostility.
Picture this
Think of a club host who gives VIP priority entry to guests wearing a specific brand of suit. The host is not turning away guests in other suits because of hatred or specific doubts about them, but is actively giving special treatment and fast-track access exclusively to the group wearing the preferred suit brand.
What the evidence says
Resumes with traditional English names maintained a consistent ~39% higher callback advantage (15.7% vs ~11.3%) regardless of whether the comparison group was a visible non-white minority (Chinese/Indian/Pakistani) or a white European minority (Greek), indicating an in-group Anglo preference rather than isolated minority-specific prejudice.
- Who was studied
- N = 12,910 resumes comparing Anglo-Saxon names against South Asian, East Asian, and Greek names in Toronto and Montreal.
- How
- Cross-ethnic correspondence experiment analyzing uniform callback gap magnitudes across diverse minority groups (Chinese, Indian, Pakistani, Greek) relative to English baseline names.
What to do
Policy interventions addressing hiring equity should focus on dismantling majority-group preference structures rather than solely trying to remedy perceived deficits in specific minority sub-groups.
From the source
"A reinterpretation of the gap between English-named applicants and those with Indian, Pakistani, or Chinese names therefore is that recruiters place a premium on wanting to interview applicants with English names rather than a discount on Indian, Pakistani, or Chinese."
Why Do Skilled Immigrants Struggle in the Labor Market? A Field Experiment with Thirteen Thousand Resumes