Try, learn and adjust
Check employers can observe referred candidates’ skills
- Plan: Claire, an employment counsellor, reviews candidate profiles for attributes that standard CVs do not show.
- Try: Highlight those attributes to employers. Arrange practical simulations or short workplace immersions, then discuss observed performance with managers.
- Learn: Read the manager’s assessment: which candidate capabilities were observed during the evaluation?
- Adjust: Keep the evaluation arrangement if performance can be assessed. Otherwise change preparation before the next referral.
Illustrative: Claire is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested learning loop: observe employer assessments and follow-up; this does not establish hiring effects from this service alone.
How
When to use
Small and medium-sized employers hesitate to recruit jobseekers whose resumes do not fully convey their actual workplace capabilities. Unobservable soft skills and potential resume gaps create hiring uncertainty for recruiters. Highlighting unobservable candidate attributes and conducting short workplace immersions allows firm managers to evaluate candidate performance before signing contracts.
Highlight unobservable candidate attributes and facilitate short workplace simulations or immersions before final hiring decisions.
- Public employment counselors review registered jobseeker profiles to identify candidate attributes that are unobservable on standard resumes.
- Counselors emphasize these specific attributes to firm managers during candidate referrals to overcome initial screening hesitancies.
- Counselors arrange candidate evaluation sessions using practical skill simulations or short workplace immersions inside the firm.
- Firm managers observe candidate performance during the workplace immersion to evaluate job fit and technical capability.
- Counselors follow up with the employer after the immersion to review candidate performance and assist with contract finalization.
Why it works
Allowing employers to observe candidate skills in a real-world setting lowers perceived hiring risks and facilitates matches for jobseekers with non-standard backgrounds.
Example
Public employment counselors across 129 local employment agencies in France offered candidate valorization and evaluation services to 3,708 small and medium-sized treatment firms during 2014. Counselors highlighted specific jobseeker attributes and conducted workplace simulations to assist firms in evaluating candidates for open roles.
About the study
Participants
7,438 small and medium-sized firms with 5 to 250 employees across 129 local employment agencies in mainland France.
Study Design
Stratified randomized controlled trial tracking specific vacancy sub-services assigned to posted permanent vacancies across a 6.5-month sanctuary period.
Results
Candidate valorization services increased by 0.004 over a 0.000 control mean (p < 0.01) and workplace evaluation services increased by 0.002 over a 0.003 control mean (p < 0.10), contributing to a 24% increase in permanent contract vacancy listings (p < 0.01) and a 10.2% increase in permanent contract hires (p < 0.05).