Restricting public visibility prevents direct candidate contacts and eliminates unqualified application floods.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Try, learn and adjust

Check applications reach the counsellor for screening

  1. Plan: Claire agrees a private vacancy listing with an employer who wants to restrict applicant volume.
  2. Try: Make the vacancy private, hide direct employer contact details and route applications through Claire for screening against agreed prerequisites.
  3. Learn: Check application flow and forwarded profiles: are referrals screened before reaching the manager?
  4. Adjust: Keep routing if applications reach screening first. Otherwise change listing settings before the next vacancy.

Illustrative: Claire is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.

See source →

School’s suggested learning loop: observe vacancy visibility, application routing and screened referrals; do not assume a hiring increase.

How

When to use

Small and medium-sized enterprise managers in slack labor markets receive an overwhelming number of job applications for open postings. Sorting through dozens of unsolicited resumes creates candidate screening bottlenecks that delay hiring. Making vacancy postings private hides direct contact details and routes all candidate applications through public employment counselors for pre-selection.

Hide open vacancy postings from public online search portals and route all candidate applications through public employment counselors.

  1. Public employment counselors consult with firm managers who want to restrict applicant volume for open positions.
  2. Counselors designate the vacancy as private in the public employment service portal, removing direct contact details or displaying only brand names.
  3. Counselors configure the job posting so jobseekers cannot apply directly to the employer or see the firm's physical address.
  4. Counselors receive all candidate applications directly and screen them against agreed-upon job prerequisites.
  5. Counselors forward only pre-screened candidate slates to the employer for final interview selection.

Why it works

Shifting pre-screening responsibilities entirely to public counselors lowers administrative screening costs for firm managers and accelerates hiring.

Example

Public employment counselors across 129 local employment agencies in France offered private vacancy listings to 3,708 small and medium-sized treatment firms during the 2014 sanctuary period. Treated firms increased their proportion of private vacancies by 57% compared to control firms, cutting direct jobseeker applications by 39%.

About the study

Participants

7,438 small and medium-sized firms with 5 to 250 employees across 129 local employment agencies in mainland France.

Study Design

Stratified randomized controlled trial measuring vacancy visibility settings and applicant volumes across a 6.5-month sanctuary period.

Results

Offering private vacancy listings increased private vacancy settings by 57% (0.030 increase over a 0.053 control mean, p < 0.01), reducing direct jobseeker applications per vacancy by 39% (-2.67 applications from a 6.862 control mean, p < 0.01).

Source

See source →