Try, learn and adjust
Check consulting matches the owner’s learning pace
- Plan: Pair Ama with a trained business consultant for a one-year engagement.
- Try: Visit her shop one to four times monthly for 30 to 60 minutes; teach records and margins and coach customer interactions.
- Learn: Review records and shop interactions: which routines has Ama adopted and which need more practice?
- Adjust: Keep instruction she can apply. Change the next visit’s pace and focus where routines remain unclear.
Illustrative: Ama is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested, untested loop. Observe records, calculations and interactions over time. The source reports no persistent average income gain from consulting.
How
When to use
Urban microenterprises often operate with poor management practices, lacking formal financial record keeping or marketing strategies. One-on-one business advice helps owners identify specific operational bottlenecks and learn foundational management routines. This approach serves small business owners who need individual guidance tailored to their specific shop conditions.
Deliver individualized management consulting to microenterprise owners directly inside their shops to improve business routines.
- Pair professional business consultants with individual microenterprise owners for a one-year advisory engagement.
- Train consultants on microenterprise coaching methods through a two-day orientation with a local small business bureau.
- Conduct one to four shop visits per month lasting 30 to 60 minutes during slow business hours.
- Teach foundational record keeping and guide the owner to calculate item profit margins and monthly income statements.
- Provide real-time feedback on customer service and employee management during active shop operations.
- Adapt the pace of instruction to the owner's learning speed, moving from simple rules of thumb to cash flow management.
Why it works
On-site feedback during actual customer interactions reinforces immediate behavioral changes in daily shop operations.
Example
Consultants worked with a 28-year-old seamstress named Sarah in Accra, Ghana, helping her introduce "sew and sell" inventory, create a dressing room area, distribute free candies to clients, and affix phone-number labels to garments. Sarah expanded her record keeping, hired a second employee, and increased her monthly profits from 90 cedis in December 2008 to 333 cedis in December 2010.
About the study
Participants
160 urban microenterprise tailors and seamstresses with five or fewer employees in Accra, Ghana.
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial comparing tailored one-on-one consulting from Ernst & Young (averaging 10 contact hours per tailor over one year) against a control group across 8 survey waves over 24 months.
Results
Consulting increased business literacy by 0.3 correct answers on a 4-question test (0.52 standard deviations, p < 0.05) and raised record keeping adoption by 45 percentage points at 6 months (p < 0.01), but average stated monthly income showed no long-term increase (+0.90 cedis, p > 0.10), and practice adoption fell to statistically insignificant levels by 24 months.