Try, learn and adjust
Check withdrawal fees are reimbursed the following week
- Plan: Obtain the operator’s weekly transaction records for enrolled accounts including Amina’s.
- Try: Calculate her withdrawal fees and reimburse the exact amount to her account the following week.
- Learn: Compare incurred fees with reimbursement amounts and dates: was the full fee returned the following week?
- Adjust: Keep the process next week if amounts and timing match. Change reconciliation where payments are missing or delayed.
Illustrative: Amina is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested, untested loop. Observe fees, reimbursement amounts and dates. Fees are charged first and reimbursed later; they are not waived at withdrawal.
How
When to use
Program managers need to encourage digital account adoption and liquid savings among cash-reliant small business owners. Transaction costs like cash withdrawal fees, which average around 5% and reach up to 10% on small amounts, discourage microentrepreneurs from depositing cash into digital accounts. Reimbursing withdrawal fees removes financial barriers and incentivizes participants to adopt digital financial tools.
Reimburse cash withdrawal fees on a weekly schedule to eliminate cash-out transaction costs for mobile account users.
- Mobile network operators generate digital transaction logs for all study participants at the end of each week.
- Project staff receive the weekly transaction summaries directly from the telecommunications provider.
- Calculate the exact cash withdrawal fees incurred by each treatment participant during the prior week.
- Reimburse the calculated fee amounts directly back into each participant's mobile money account the following week.
- Continue weekly fee reimbursements throughout the active intervention period to maintain zero-cost cash withdrawals.
Why it works
Providing a temporary fee waiver encourages microentrepreneurs to experiment with digital accounts, experience their security benefits, and build ongoing digital savings habits.
Example
In Blantyre, Malawi, project staff reimbursed withdrawal fees weekly to 320 treatment microentrepreneurs over the study duration, offsetting average withdrawal fees of 5% and driving an average of $90.31 in total deposits per participant.
About the study
Participants
320 treatment microentrepreneurs in Blantyre, Malawi.
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial offering weekly cash withdrawal fee reimbursements based on telecom administrative transaction records.
Results
Weekly fee reimbursements offset an average 5% fee schedule, enabling 73% of treated respondents to make deposits (averaging $90.31 across 10.83 deposits) and 53% to make at least 5 deposits.