Original source
Do Labor Market Opportunities Affect Young Women’s Work and Family Decisions? Experimental Evidence from India
Journal article · The Quarterly Journal of Economics · 127, 753–792 · Version date: 3 March 2012
Read the source ↗© The Author(s) 2012. All rights reserved.
Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Full source notice
c The Author(s) 2012. Published by Oxford University Press, on the behalf of President and Fellows of Harvard College. All rights reserved. For Permissions, please email: journals. permissions@oup.com.
Used in these cards
Target career orientation and labor return interventions at upper-primary and adolescent students facing high structural dropout risks.
"Girls 6-10 (primary school age) were 3.1 percentage points more likely to be enrolled in treatment villages, but the effect is not statistically significant... For girls 11-17, the treatment resulted in a 5.9 percentage point gain (significant at the 5% level)."
Increase visible future career opportunities for women to motivate parents to immediately invest more resources in young daughters' health and education.
"Significantly, we also find that even younger, school-aged girls had increased school enrollment and greater body mass index (BMI), reflecting better nutrition and/or health investments."
Target labor market interventions specifically by gender when attempting to close gender-specific gaps in education and workforce participation.
"In sharp contrast to the results for women, there are no effects for young men... the recruiting treatment had no impact on enrollment, training, employment, or marriage for young men."
Expand high-return labor force opportunities targeted at young women to incentivize voluntary delays in early marriage and childbearing.
"Women from treatment villages aged 15 to 21 at baseline, the peak age range for marriage and the initiation of childbearing in rural India, were 5-6 percentage points less likely to get married or to have given birth over the three-year period of our intervention."
Monitor detailed household expenditure shares alongside total consumption to identify how credit-constrained families internally reallocate funds to afford human capital investments.
"Consistent with these gains, and the high costs of schooling in India... the treatment led to an increase in the budget share devoted to schooling in households with school-aged girls."
Design youth economic empowerment initiatives that explicitly emphasize long-term career progression and post-maternity workforce re-entry.
"The desire to work before marriage is around 13 percentage points higher for women from treatment villages. The share who want to work after marriage... and after their children are older increase by 10-11 percentage points."
Evaluate youth economic empowerment programs using restricted subsample analyses to verify that human capital gains are driven by direct child opportunity returns rather than adult intrahousehold power reallocations.
"The treatment does not have a statistically significant impact on women's participation in decision making for schooling and health specifically, or for overall decision making and women's autonomy..."
Design youth education and labor market interventions targeting first-generation learners by directly communicating economic returns to illiterate parents.
"The increase in enrollment for girls was not limited to households with educated parents... even uneducated parents increased investments in their daughters' schooling when presented with clear evidence of labor market returns."
Establish partnerships between private vocational training academies and emerging growth industries to encourage individual skill investment.
"Column (1) of Table IV shows that women 18-24 in treatment villages were 2.8 percentage points more likely to be enrolled in such programs... indicating a willingness to invest in human capital to get a job or build a career when suitable opportunities are available."
Utilize body mass index (BMI) z-scores rather than height-for-age z-scores when evaluating short-to-medium term nutritional improvements in child health interventions.
"The treatment led to a statistically significant increase in BMI-for-age z-scores for girls... However, there was no statistically significant effect of the treatment on height-for-age z-scores."
Increase economic returns to adult female labor to combat male-biased resource distribution within households during early childhood.
"The effect of the recruiting treatment on BMI-for-age z-scores is positive and statistically significant at the 1 percent level for girls... In contrast, there is no effect of the treatment on the BMI of boys."
Promote service-sector and digital infrastructure expansion in rural areas to generate respectable, non-manual employment options for women.
"Boserup (1970), Costa (2000), Goldin (1990, 1995, 2006)... argue that there may be less of a social stigma associated with women working in white-collar jobs. These jobs are considered safer and 'cleaner' than manual labor..."