Original source
Ever Failed, Try Again, Succeed Better: Results from a Randomized Educational Intervention on Grit (2016)
working paper
Search for this source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Deploy non-cognitive development programs during middle childhood (ages 8–10) to capitalize on early brain plasticity before adolescent behavioral patterns solidify.
"Our results provide an affirmative answer to the question of whether non-cognitive skills are malleable, and highlight a particular low-cost alternative that can be implemented to foster these skills in the natural environment of the classroom."
Train elementary teachers to deliver effort-focused feedback and animated case studies during extracurricular hours to reframe student setbacks as opportunities for skill accumulation.
"Treated students score 0.28 standard deviations higher in a standardized math test, and 0.13 standard deviations higher in a standardized Turkish test at follow-up."
Design perseverance curricula that target beliefs about effort productivity rather than attempting to boost general self-esteem or artificial self-confidence.
"However, we do not estimate any significant treatment effect on confidence scores (column 3), which suggests that a boost in self-confidence is unlikely to be the mechanism through which the estimated results were obtained."
Validate social policy interventions by executing an independent replication RCT on a secondary cohort prior to authorizing full-scale institutional rollout.
"We find that the estimated treatment effects are remarkably similar across the two independent samples in which we randomize the educational intervention. The replicability of our results is encouraging and clears the path for a potential scale-up."
Train instructors to replace outcome-and-intelligence praise with specific feedback highlighting the direct link between student effort and skill improvement.
"Teachers were also encouraged not to praise a successful student in a way which would imply that the student possesses superior intelligence (in the innate sense of the word), but were rather advised to highlight the role of effort in the student's success."
Implement forced probabilistic assignment to challenging condition rounds in experimental trials to evaluate post-failure persistence free of selection bias.
"This procedure allows us to have a random subset of children where the effects of 1st round feedback on 2nd round task choices can be analyzed free of selection."
Measure non-cognitive traits using incentivized real-effort tasks with dynamic difficulty switching and randomized feedback exposure rather than relying exclusively on questionnaires.
"The incentivized real effort task is designed to elicit a number of characteristics of grit; challenge seeking, perseverance through setbacks, goal setting and the propensity to engage in effortful behavior to accumulate skill."
Structure skill development programs so participants select ambitious performance targets well in advance while providing self-directed preparation materials during the intervening period.
Pair ambitious goal selection with structured, voluntary practice workbooks distributed over multi-day intervals to foster deliberate practice before evaluation.
"When given time (exactly one week) to acquire the skill needed to succeed in the difficult task, treated students are not only significantly more likely to set for themselves the goal of succeeding in the difficult task, but they are also significantly more likely to achieve this goal."
Isolate multi-component non-cognitive curricula into single-trait evaluation arms to confirm independent treatment efficacy prior to bundling programs.
"While we can evaluate the independent impact of the patience treatment on our outcome measures (and indeed show that the patience treatment by itself does not produce gritty behavior), we are not able to isolate or rule out potential complementarities... The second study... resolves this issue."
Schedule non-cognitive intervention modules strictly within Ministry-designated discretionary or free play hours to prevent displacement of core academic instructional time.
"In the absence of any projects, students use the free hours as unstructured playtime, so these projects do not crowd-out any core teaching."
Calculate expected success probabilities based on historical baseline metrics before task selection to ensure participants choose difficulty levels that maximize total expected yield.
"In Sample B, students are more likely to choose the payoff-maximizing task in both visits. In particular, treated students are 14 percentage points more likely to make the payoff-maximizing choice in visit 1, and 10 percentage points more likely to make the payoff-maximizing choice in visit 2."
Reframe task evaluation matrices to explicitly demonstrate how incremental units of practice translate into predictable percentage increases in output performance.
"Estimated treatment effects on beliefs and behaviors suggest that the treatment might have affected students' beliefs about the productivity of effort in the skill accumulation process, thereby leading to more ambitious goal-setting, a higher propensity to engage in skill accumulating activities, and consequently to higher success."