Try, learn and adjust
Check weekly rewards follow both loan targets
- Plan: Set Meena’s new-loan and renewal targets for the first two weeks of the month.
- Try: Track progress midweek and at week end; award vouchers after a week meeting both goals.
- Learn: Check whether eligible officers received the non-cash prize promptly.
- Adjust: Keep prompt voucher delivery next target week; correct missed eligible awards.
Illustrative: Meena is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →Both targets and voucher receipt: about 30,000 COP or USD 15, worth 2% of average monthly salary. Do not attribute the combined programme’s effects to prizes alone. School’s suggested learning loop, not a source-tested cycle.
How
When to use
Frontline staff under long monthly incentive cycles often delay effort until the final weeks because distant monetary commissions lack short-term salience. Offering modest, weekly in-kind prizes creates immediate, tangible focus for employees facing unpleasant or routine tasks. This intervention targets field workers and sales staff prone to time-management and procrastination problems.
Reward employees with frequent, small non-cash prizes for meeting short-term weekly targets to keep performance goals salient throughout the month.
- Bank managers establish weekly target thresholds for new loan placement and credit renewals during the first two weeks of each month.
- Managers track individual performance halfway through and at the end of each target week.
- Program administrators award non-cash gift certificates worth 2 percent of average monthly salary (approximately 30,000 COP or 15 USD) to officers who meet both new credit and renewal goals in the same week.
- Program administrators provide prizes as tangible vouchers for movies, informal restaurant meals, grocery store purchases, or phone credits, strictly avoiding cash disbursements.
- Managers distribute prizes directly after the target week to provide immediate positive feedback.
Why it works
Non-cash rewards create emotional resonance and focus employee attention on short-term time management rather than distant end-of-month bonuses.
Example
In Colombia, Bancamía provided loan officers in 31 treatment branches with gift certificates worth 30,000 COP (\$15 USD) for achieving both new loan and renewal targets in week one or week two. Over the six-month program, the bank awarded 284 prizes (averaging 1.4 prizes per month per branch), helping boost loan officer goal achievement by 70 percentage points when paired with manager support.
About the study
Participants
61 bank branches (31 treatment, 30 control) and 388 loan officers in Colombia (47% female, average age 29.4 years, average 15 years of education).
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial tracking monthly administrative pay and performance data from June 2008 to April 2009 using OLS panel regressions with branch fixed effects and standard errors clustered at the branch level.
Results
Offering weekly in-kind prizes worth 2% of salary helped increase total monthly employee compensation by 25% to 30% (COP 334,133 to 421,469; p < 0.01) and monthly bonus earnings by COP 203,042 to 228,628 (p < 0.01), showing workers previously left money on the table due to procrastination.