Incentivizing supervisors aligns managerial priorities with frontline goals, turning managers into active agents who reinforce weekly deadlines.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Try, learn and adjust

Check manager support accompanies team incentives

  1. Plan: Include Meena, a branch manager, in the second-phase monthly award scheme.
  2. Try: Review weekly progress, encourage officers and track the stated 50% team threshold.
  3. Learn: Read branch goal reports to see whether the threshold was met and awards followed.
  4. Adjust: Keep weekly reviews next month; correct award or reporting gaps before the next cycle.

Illustrative: Meena is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.

See source →

Team goal reports and manager awards; this phase follows the officer-only phase. School’s suggested learning loop, not a source-tested cycle.

How

When to use

Frontline employee incentives often fail to improve performance when supervisors lack motivation to reinforce target deadlines. Providing direct rewards to branch managers aligns supervisory attention with employee targets. This approach helps financial institutions and organizations engage mid-level managers as active coaches for field staff.

Offer monthly team performance awards and recognition to branch managers whose staff meet weekly placement goals.

  1. Bank administrators establish weekly team performance targets requiring 50 percent of branch loan officers to meet early placement goals.
  2. Program managers track branch-level weekly goal attainment across all participating loan officers every month.
  3. Bank leaders award monthly prizes to branch managers whose branches achieve the 50 percent team goal threshold.
  4. Program leaders enter top-performing branch managers into long-term grand prize competitions and feature their names in monthly bulletin updates.
  5. Direct supervisors conduct weekly progress meetings to review performance reports and encourage loan officers to achieve their placement targets.

Why it works

Managerial encouragement keeps targets salient and provides crucial planning support to procrastinating employees.

Example

In Colombia, Bancamía introduced manager incentives during the second phase of the Madrugador Program across 31 treatment branches, awarding managers monthly prizes when 50 percent of their branch loan officers met weekly placement goals. This manager-level incentive drove loan officer goal achievement up by 70 percentage points compared to control branches.

About the study

Participants

61 bank branches (31 treatment, 30 control) and 388 loan officers in Colombia.

Study Design

Randomized controlled trial comparing Phase 1 (loan officer incentives only, Nov 2008 to Jan 2009) to Phase 2 (manager incentives added, Feb to Apr 2009) using OLS regressions with time and branch fixed effects and clustered standard errors.

Results

Introducing branch manager incentives increased loan officer weekly target achievement by 69.8 percentage points (p < 0.10; 85.4 percentage points with controls, p < 0.05) and reduced the monthly workload gap indicator by 9.58 points (p < 0.05), whereas Phase 1 without manager incentives yielded no statistically significant effect (-0.081, p > 0.10).

Source

See source →