Independent logbook tracking prevents data entry errors or reporting biases from distorting official delinquency metrics.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research procedure

Cross-check repayment records

  1. Record meeting date, attendance and paying clients
  2. Maintain the logbook at each fortnightly meeting
  3. Compare logbook defaults with central passbook records

Illustrative summary of the source’s parallel record checks. Logbooks recorded 4.9 percent default; administrative records recorded 5.4 percent. These are different records, not successive default rates.

See source →

How

When to use

Microfinance evaluators need to verify the accuracy of official bank repayment records during field experiments. Relying on a single administrative database risks misclassifying loan delinquency or meeting attendance. Maintaining a separate field logbook provides an independent cross-check on client default rates and meeting execution.

Record biweekly group meeting details in a dedicated field logbook to cross-validate administrative loan repayment records.

  1. Issue a specialized meeting activity logbook to each loan officer managing experimental borrowing groups.
  2. Attend every scheduled group repayment meeting at the designated member home.
  3. Record the exact calendar date of the group meeting in the logbook.
  4. Count and log the total number of borrowing clients present at the meeting.
  5. Write down the full names of all individual clients who make a loan payment during the meeting.
  6. Compare logbook default records against central administrative passbook data at the end of the loan cycle.

Why it works

Cross-checking physical meeting records against computerized passbook entries validates experimental findings on borrower default.

Example

Loan officers recorded meeting dates, attendance, and repayment names in experimental logbooks across 169 loan groups in Kolkata. Logbook records showed a 4.9 percent client default rate, validating the 5.4 percent default rate recorded in official administrative database records.

About the study

Participants

845 low-income female microfinance clients in 169 loan groups in Kolkata, India.

Study Design

Parallel record-keeping trial comparing experimental meeting logbooks maintained by loan officers against central MFI administrative passbook databases.

Results

Meeting activity logbook tracking recorded a 4.9 percent default rate across experimental groups, closely validating the 5.4 percent default rate identified in official administrative passbook records.

Source

See source →