Providing commissions on successfully delivered payments incentivizes banks and customer service providers to resolve logistical challenges and implement the system correctly.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Try, learn and adjust

Check commissions follow delivered payments

  1. Plan: Set the contracted bank’s commission at 2 percent of payments delivered to recipients such as Meena.
  2. Try: Local agents authenticate fingerprints and disburse cash in villages. Pay the bank against delivered funds.
  3. Learn: Compare completed disbursements and commissions: was the 2 percent rule applied to delivered payments?
  4. Adjust: Keep verified commission calculations next period. Change calculations that include undelivered funds or the wrong rate.

Illustrative: Meena is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.

See source →

School’s suggested, untested loop. Observe delivered cash and bank commissions. The wider payment-system evaluation does not isolate commission effects.

How

When to use

Government payment reforms often stall because financial intermediaries lack motivation to deliver funds efficiently. Paying a percentage-based commission on delivered funds incentivizes contracted banks and service providers to distribute social welfare payments correctly. This aligns implementation interests across payment providers and rural program beneficiaries.

Offer percentage-based commission fees to contracted banks and service providers tied directly to the volume of social assistance funds successfully disbursed.

  1. Government agencies contract private banks to manage social assistance distribution across targeted administrative sub-districts.
  2. Program administrators set a performance-based commission rate of 2 percent on all payments delivered to beneficiaries.
  3. Contracted banks deploy local customer service providers to village locations to process biometric payment transactions.
  4. Local providers authenticate beneficiary identities using fingerprint readers and disburse cash payments directly in villages.
  5. Government agencies calculate total successfully delivered disbursements and pay contracted banks the 2 percent commission fee.

Why it works

Aligned financial incentives motivate service providers to ensure payments reach intended recipients in a timely manner.

Example

The Government of Andhra Pradesh incentivized contracted banks and Customer Service Providers by rewarding them a 2 percent commission on all NREGS and SSP payments delivered. This financial commission helped sustain the rollout across 296 sub-districts, where total annual system operating costs were US\$4 million for NREGS and US\$2.3 million for SSP.

About the study

Participants

8,000 households in 8 districts of Andhra Pradesh, covering a rural population of nineteen million people.

Study Design

Cluster-randomized controlled trial across 296 sub-districts randomly assigned to early rollout (treatment) or delayed rollout (comparison) over two years.

Results

Paying a 2 percent commission supported payment delivery across treatment areas, contributing to a US\$38.5 million annual leakage reduction for NREGS and US\$3.2 million for SSP against annual implementation costs of US\$4 million for NREGS and US\$2.3 million for SSP.

Source

See source →