Research procedure
Announce guaranteed bonuses before testing
- Review the referral contract with both participants
- Before tasks, tell both the maximum bonus is guaranteed
- Test the candidate without direct performance pay; pay referrer
Illustrative summary of the source-described bonus procedure. The guarantee is announced before testing; payment occurs at session completion, regardless of candidate performance.
See source →How
When to use
Announce a guaranteed maximum bonus payout to referring workers before their referred candidates perform job tasks. This eliminates private side payments from referrers to candidates that would otherwise motivate candidate task effort. Use this protocol when researchers or employers need to isolate peer screening capability from candidate effort responses.
Inform referring workers and their candidates before task execution that the maximum performance bonus will be paid to the referrer regardless of candidate performance.
- Welcome the original worker and their referred candidate to the testing laboratory site.
- Review the assigned performance-contingent referral bonus contract details with both individuals.
- Inform both the referring worker and the candidate simultaneously before any task begins that the referrer will receive the maximum possible performance bonus.
- Administer the job tasks to the referred candidate without offering the candidate any direct financial performance incentives.
- Pay the referring worker the full maximum performance bonus upon completion of the session.
Why it works
This ensures candidate performance reflects baseline ability and peer selection rather than financial motivation.
Example
Field staff informed 407 returning referrals and original participants in Kolkata, India, that the referrer would receive the full performance bonus regardless of test results. This neutralized potential side payments across all performance pay treatments while evaluating cognitive task scores.
About the study
Participants
407 returning referrals and original male participants in Kolkata, India.
Study Design
Experimental design protocol informing participants of guaranteed maximum bonus disbursement prior to candidate task execution.
Results
Successfully eliminated candidate side payment incentives, allowing researchers to observe an 0.371 standard deviation productivity premium from referrals selected by incentivized high-ability participants.