Try, learn and adjust
Check referrals meet agreed job requirements
- Plan: Claire meets the employer to agree 1 to 5 non-negotiable prerequisites that the public vacancy may not show.
- Try: Record the prerequisites in the placement database. Refer only applicants who meet all agreed criteria.
- Learn: Compare referred profiles with the recorded prerequisites: do all meet them?
- Adjust: Keep the screening process if profiles match. Otherwise change profile verification before the next referral.
Illustrative: Claire is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested learning loop: observe recorded prerequisites and referral matches; this check does not establish faster hiring.
How
When to use
Employers often struggle to specify unobservable or soft-skill hiring requirements in standard vacancy listings. Unclear job specifications lead to high volumes of mismatched applications and screening bottlenecks for hiring managers. Establishing clear prerequisite criteria helps small and medium-sized enterprise managers filter candidates before interviews.
Co-define non-negotiable prerequisite criteria with hiring managers to filter candidates prior to candidate referral.
- Public employment counselors meet with firm managers upon vacancy submission to discuss job demands.
- Counselors work with the employer to establish between 1 and 5 non-negotiable prerequisite criteria that may not be observable in the public job posting.
- Counselors record these specific prerequisite criteria in the placement management database.
- Counselors evaluate incoming jobseeker profiles against the co-defined prerequisite criteria before referring candidates.
- Counselors forward only those applicants who meet all agreed-upon prerequisite criteria to the employer.
Why it works
This prevents unqualified candidate referrals and accelerates firm hiring decisions.
Example
Public employment counselors across 129 local employment agencies in France co-defined special prerequisite criteria with firm managers for vacancies posted by 3,708 treatment firms. Treated firms experienced a 122% increase in the usage of prerequisite screening services compared to control firms.
About the study
Participants
7,438 small and medium-sized firms with 5 to 250 employees across 129 local employment agencies in mainland France.
Study Design
Stratified randomized controlled trial tracking specific vacancy sub-services assigned to posted permanent vacancies during a 6.5-month sanctuary period.
Results
Co-defining prerequisite screening criteria led to a 122% increase in prerequisite service provision (0.028 increase over a 0.034 control mean, p < 0.01), contributing to a 24% increase in permanent vacancy postings (p < 0.01) and a 10.2% increase in permanent contract hires (p < 0.05).