Restricting candidate slates shifts the heavy initial screening burden away from firm managers to public counselors.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Try, learn and adjust

Check restricted referrals match vacancy requirements

  1. Plan: Claire reviews experience, skills and education against the employer’s vacancy requirements.
  2. Try: Verify exact matches. Agree a delivery schedule and send a restricted list with a maximum of 5 to 10 candidates per post.
  3. Learn: Check referral numbers and requirements: is candidate volume below expectations, and do profiles match?
  4. Adjust: Keep screening if the list matches requirements. If volume is low, propose revised criteria to the employer for the next referral.

Illustrative: Claire is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.

See source →

School’s suggested learning loop: observe list size, profile matches and delivery timing; this check does not establish hiring effects.

How

When to use

Small and medium-sized employers in slack labor markets are overwhelmed by large volumes of job applications for open postings. Sorting through dozens of unqualified resumes consumes manager time and creates recruitment bottlenecks. Employment counselors verify candidate qualifications and restrict referral lists to a small slate of matching applicants.

Verify jobseeker profiles against posted vacancy requirements and limit candidate referrals to a pre-screened list for employer review.

  1. Employment counselors review incoming jobseeker profiles against posted experience, skill, and education specifications.
  2. Counselors verify that candidate qualifications match all job requirements exactly.
  3. Counselors limit the referral list to a maximum of 5 to 10 matching candidates per position.
  4. Counselors negotiate a firm delivery schedule for sending the pre-screened candidate list to the hiring manager.
  5. Counselors monitor applicant flow and propose adjustments to job criteria if candidate volume falls below expectations.

Why it works

Delivering a small list of pre-verified candidates accelerates employer interview decisions and lowers total recruitment costs.

Example

Public employment counselors across 129 local agencies in France provided profile verification and screening for vacancies posted by 3,708 treatment firms during the 2014 sanctuary period. Counselors restricted referral slates to a maximum of 5 to 10 pre-screened applicants per position. This service contributed to a 24% increase in permanent vacancy postings and a 10.2% increase in permanent contract hires.

About the study

Participants

7,438 small and medium-sized firms with 5 to 250 employees across 129 local employment agencies in mainland France.

Study Design

Stratified randomized controlled trial measuring candidate screening services and match volume across a 6.5-month sanctuary period.

Results

Provision of profile verification and candidate pre-screening increased from 2.7% among control vacancies to 6.0% among treatment vacancies (+0.033, p < 0.01), reducing total organic jobseeker applications by 39% (-2.67 applications per vacancy, p < 0.01).

Source

See source →