Research groups
Estimate net apprenticeship creation
Double-sided trial data: use assigned status as an instrument
- Youth windfall
- Divide reduced traditional participation by formal programme entry.
- Firm substitution
- Divide displaced traditional apprentices by formal placements per firm.
Illustrative summary of source-described calculations. Bound net creation between one minus windfall and one minus substitution. Reported parameters: 0.259 (p < 0.001) and 0.227 (p = 0.128), giving bounds of 74.1% to 77.3%.
See source →How
When to use
Evaluators testing employment subsidies need to measure total job creation without overcounting participants who displaced unsubsidized workers. Single-sided evaluations miss displacement on the employer side or deadweight participation on the applicant side. Combining youth windfall rates and firm substitution parameters establishes rigorous bounds for net job creation across the market.
Quantify net job creation by combining youth windfall parameters and firm substitution parameters derived from double-sided experimental data.
- Estimate the youth windfall parameter by dividing the reduction in traditional informal apprenticeships by the total number of formal apprentices entering the program.
- Estimate the firm substitution parameter by dividing the displacement of traditional apprentices in host enterprises by the number of formal apprentices placed per firm.
- Calculate the instrumental variable estimators for youth participation and host firm apprentice intake using assigned treatment status as the instrument.
- Bound the net rate of job creation between one minus the windfall parameter and one minus the substitution parameter.
Why it works
Combining both bounds net employment creation independently of unobserved labor market tightness adjustments.
Example
Evaluators in Côte d'Ivoire estimated a youth windfall parameter of 0.259 and a firm substitution parameter of 0.227 across 731 microenterprises and 1,842 youth applicants, bounding net job creation between 74.1 percent and 77.3 percent of placed formal apprentices.
About the study
Participants
1,842 eligible youth applicants aged 18 to 24 and 731 informal microenterprises across 7 urban localities in Côte d'Ivoire.
Study Design
Instrumental variable estimation using double-sided randomized trial assignment to calculate youth windfall and firm substitution parameters.
Results
The youth windfall parameter was 0.259 (p < 0.001) and the firm substitution parameter was 0.227 (p = 0.128), establishing that net job creation was between 74.1 percent and 77.3 percent of formal placements.