Original source
Direct and Indirect Effects of Subsidized Dual Apprenticeships
Discussion paper · IZA Institute of Labor Economics · IZA Discussion Paper 12793 · Version date: November 2019
Search for this source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Randomize program eligibility simultaneously on both the applicant supply side and firm demand side to identify substitution parameters and net macro-level employment impacts.
"To simultaneously measure direct effects among individuals and indirect (substitution) effects in firms, we set up a double-sided experiment. Specifically, we randomize whether interested youths were assigned to a formal apprenticeship, and whether apprenticeship positions opened by firms were filled with formal apprentices."
Account for self-selection shifts toward higher-educated participants when evaluating subsidized dual training programs to isolate human capital gains from baseline worker quality.
"Compared to traditional apprentices in control firms, formal apprentices are 48 percentage points less likely to have no education, 35 percentage points more likely to have completed primary school, and 13 percentage points more likely to have completed lower secondary school."
Complement informal enterprise apprenticeships with mandated, externally monitored theoretical coursework to guarantee general skill delivery and overcome firm commitment failures.
"The dual approach can resolve potential commitment failures in firms by ensuring that formal apprentices receive general skill training in vocational centers."
Measure host-firm displacement parameters ($\psi$) in subsidized employment schemes to ensure net position creation remains significantly above zero.
"Substitution effects are also observed: for each formal apprentice placed, 0.23 traditional apprentices is displaced... the net number of new apprenticeship positions created is between 0.74 and 0.77 percent of the number of formal apprentices placed."
Track host-firm allowance reductions and fee adjustments in subsidized stipend programs to quantify the implicit transfer of public subsidies from trainees to enterprise owners.
"The firms internalize that the program subsidy covers such costs, so they strongly reduce their contribution. This behavioral response from firms implies in turn that part of the program subsidy is in fact transmitted to firms."
Structure multi-sided interventions so supply-side participant withdrawals equal demand-side firm replacements to maintain stable market tightness and prevent control group spillover contamination.
"The order of magnitude of the change in the market tightness is $\sigma(\psi-\omega)$, where $\sigma$ is the size of the experiment... The results confirm this feature of the experiment: the tightness adjustment is very small in practice. Control firms and youths are thus unlikely to be affected by spill-overs due to changes in market conditions."
Incorporate master trainer time reallocation and lost billable production hours into net enterprise profit evaluations of workplace training programs.
"The provision of training also has an opportunity cost for firms, including the opportunity cost of time of mastercraftmen. Finding zero effects on profits is consistent with these effects cancelling each others."
Compute the net value of trainee work by subtracting total employer compensation from the estimated market cost of hiring casual labor for identical tasks.
"Observing a positive impact is highly suggestive that apprentices are paid below their productivity... This increase amounts to 21 380 FCFA per month, more than doubling the net value of work performed by apprentices in control firms."
Evaluate job skill accumulation in informal labor markets by tracking changes in worker task composition toward non-routine analytical activities using a standardized task intensity index.
"Youths assigned to formal apprenticeship are more involved in non routine analytical tasks. This is consistent with an improvement in skills and in average productivity."
Combine external theoretical exams with standardized practical assessments to provide portable skill certification that overcomes labor market information asymmetries.
"Lastly, we also observe a substantial increase in the share of youths receiving training certification, which constitutes a mechanism to signal they have acquired general skills."
Combine direct monthly stipends to trainees with formal theoretical instruction and standardized skill certification to overcome capital constraints and firm commitment failures.
"Four years after the start of the experiment, treated youths perform more complex tasks and their earnings are higher by 15 percent. We conclude that subsidized dual apprenticeships expand access to training, upgrade skills and improve earnings for youths without crowding out traditional apprentices."
Estimate unconditional quantile treatment effects and run permutation-based rank-sum tests to confirm program earnings gains are distributed across the entire income distribution.
"The figure shows that the proportion of youths who earn less than a given amount is uniformly and significantly lower in the treatment group than in the control group. This suggests robust positive program impacts on earnings across the distribution."
Structure participant stipends to match or exceed lost casual labor earnings to eliminate short-term financial barriers during intensive training programs.
"The subsidy contributes to offset these losses in labor earnings, so that the program has no significant impact on youths' total earnings in the short-term."
Calculate the proportion of subsidized participants who would have pursued informal private training absent the subsidy to establish the net supply-side addition to total human capital.
"The share of youths entering formal apprenticeship over the course of the experiment increases by 71.2 percentage points... The difference between the two estimates shows that 18.5 percent of treated youths would have entered traditional apprenticeship in the absence of the intervention, a significant windfall effect."
Apply Within/Between sector task decompositions to verify whether vocational training increases worker productivity within specific trades versus driving cross-sector occupational shifts.
"Importantly, however, there is also a significant increase in the within component of non-routine analytical tasks, showing that treated youths perform more of these tasks even within occupations. This contributes to the decrease in the overall routine task intensity index."