Try, learn and adjust
Check commitment savings settlement
- Plan: Meena offers voluntary CARES accounts: minimum deposit 50 pesos, with no withdrawals for six months.
- Try: Clients deposit weekly. At six months, technicians test urine for nicotine and cotinine; return balances for passes, donate balances to charity for failures.
- Learn: Compare each test result with the balance destination: was the settlement rule followed?
- Adjust: Keep correct settlements as the model for subsequent accounts. Change an incorrect balance destination before the next settlement.
Illustrative: Meena is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested learning loop checks test-based settlement, separately from the tested savings contract.
How
When to use
Many smokers want to quit but suffer from self-control problems and present-bias that cause them to delay quitting. This method offers smokers a formal commitment contract where they voluntarily deposit money into a locked account for six months. It helps self-aware smokers create a financial penalty for failing to achieve their health goals.
Offer smokers a restricted savings account where deposited balances are returned only upon passing a biochemical smoking test six months later.
- Bank marketers offer regular smokers a voluntary commitment savings account called CARES.
- Clients open the account with a minimum deposit of 50 pesos.
- Clients deposit the money usually spent on cigarettes into the account every week for six months.
- The bank prohibits all withdrawals during the six-month commitment period.
- Trained bank technicians administer a urine strip test for nicotine and cotinine six months after account opening.
- The bank returns the entire balance to clients who pass the test or donates the money to charity if they fail.
Why it works
Depositing savings into a locked account converts a distant health outcome into an immediate financial incentive to remain smoke-free.
Example
Green Bank offered the CARES account to 781 regular smokers in the Philippines, and 83 individuals opened accounts with an average balance of 553 pesos committed at six months.
About the study
Participants
781 regular smokers offered CARES (part of a 2,000 participant study) on Mindanao island in the Philippines, averaging 37 years of age and 14 cigarettes per day.
Study Design
Randomized controlled field experiment where marketers offered eligible smokers the CARES commitment savings product and evaluated smoking status at 6 and 12 months using urine test strips.
Results
Offering CARES increased 12-month urine test passage rates by 3.4 to 5.7 percentage points relative to the control group, representing a 35 to 36 percent relative increase in smoking cessation.