Original source
Financial Education and Financial Access for Transnational Households: Field Experimental Evidence from the Philippines (2016)
working paper
Search for this source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Prioritize financial access interventions specifically on underserved risk-coping products like micro-insurance rather than expanding existing formal credit and savings access in saturated markets.
"In addition, while we find no evidence of constraints in access to formal credit and savings products, our results do suggest that access constraints exist in the formal insurance market."
Apply multiple-inference corrections (such as Benjamini-Hochberg q-values) when evaluating broad multi-outcome household welfare impacts to prevent false positives in program evaluations.
"We do not find statistically significant impacts of the treatments on any of the groups of outcome variables. While effects on individual variables are occasionally statistically significantly different from zero, we examine a large number of outcome variables, and when we make corrections for multiple inference we cannot reject the hypothesis of no effect on broader measures of household well-being."
Facilitate low-cost international transfer channels to maximize the developmental and human-capital impacts of migrant income gains in origin countries.
"Households in the Philippines experiencing exogenous increases in remittances become more likely to leave poverty status, to send their children to school, and to invest in entrepreneurial enterprises (Yang & Martinez 2005, Yang 2008a)."
Evaluate target populations using direct financial literacy assessments rather than relying on general educational attainment as a proxy for financial capability.
"Though average education levels are quite high (approximately 16 years of education), financial literacy scores at baseline are low. Only 20% of the sample answered both financial literacy questions in our survey correctly, suggesting a possible benefit of financial education."
Budget and deploy direct participant compensation (such as attendance stipends) when launching field interventions to overcome initial adoption friction and achieve adequate statistical power.
"Four months into the project, only 36 had participated in our financial education sessions out of the 487 invited. In the same period, only 4 individuals had availed of the BPI savings account following our invitations, while only one person had obtained an ASKI microloan... Starting January 2015, we provided financial incentives to encourage households to take-up the treatments."
Deploy targeted financial literacy workshops focusing on budgeting and debt management to guide indebted households toward lower-risk formal credit channels.
"In response to the financial education treatment (whether alone or in combination with financial access), study participants changed their borrowing decisions: they borrowed lower amounts on average, and (conditional on borrowing) shifted their borrowing from sources of credit that are informal (family and friends) to formal ones (e.g., banks and MFIs)."
Assess baseline household remittance inflows and liquidity before deploying subsidized microcredit programs targeted at migrant families.
"Only nine individuals ended up opening BPI savings accounts, and only two took up the ASKI credit product. Regression coefficients in the credit regression are all very small in magnitude and not statistically significantly different from zero."
Design cross-border financial products that grant overseas remittance senders direct legal control or joint monitoring over destination bank accounts.
"Ashraf et al (2015) find in a randomized study among migrants from El Salvador that improving monitoring and control over savings (by providing new types of savings accounts that allow migrant joint- or sole-ownership) leads to higher savings in the home country."
Expand digital mobile money transfer infrastructure to facilitate domestic risk-sharing and reduce transaction costs for informal safety nets.
"Jack and Suri (2014) and Blumenstock (2016) find that internal remittances via mobile (cellphone) money systems contribute to risk-sharing within Kenya and Rwanda, respectively."
Structure financial capability evaluations using multi-arm factorial designs that isolate budgeting, goal-setting, and product instruction modules.
"For example, impacts we found of financial education raise the question of what aspect of financial education is having the impact: is it advice on budget and planning, or facilitation of household goal-setting, or more detailed information on how to use specific financial services such as credit and savings? Future studies could randomize the inclusion of these specific sub-components of financial education to tease out which are leading to changed financial behaviors."
Conduct pre-intervention baseline diagnostics on local product saturation and institutional preferences before deploying subsidized formal savings accounts.
"The dominant response by far (given by 46.9% of respondents) was that they preferred other establishments instead of BPI for savings products... That households felt that they had better products to avail of in the market also helps support the conclusion that households are not constrained in their access to savings products."
Evaluate and budget financial education and financial access programs independently based on standalone costs and benefits rather than expecting combined delivery to boost participant adoption.
"We find no evidence of complementarities between the financial education and financial access treatments."
Design disaster relief and economic stabilization programs that complement rather than disrupt existing international remittance inflow channels during emergency shocks.
"In addition, remittances appear to serve as insurance, rising in the wake of negative shocks (Yang & Choi 2007, Yang 2008b)."
Require joint participation of both overseas migrants and home-country decision-makers when implementing financial education or remittance-channeling initiatives.
"Doi, McKenzie, and Zia (2014) examined the impact of pre-departure financial education training in Indonesia, finding that training has positive impacts on financial practices and on savings when migrants and family members are trained together."