Research comparison
Describe bundled contract offers
Prepay three half-price visits at Rs. 15 each over six months
- Fixed deposit
- Offer an additional Rs. 45 commitment deposit.
- Personalised deposit
- Let patients choose an additional deposit starting at Rs. 0.
Illustrative summary of the described bundled contract terms. Return one-third of the deposit per completed visit; retain unreturned funds after six months. Across purchasers, 62% to 77% made no visit; bundling did not improve committed behaviour.
See source →How
When to use
Many individuals suffer from present bias and procrastinate on preventive healthcare, but lack interest in standard commitment contracts. Health providers need a way to increase interest in preventive health monitoring among at-risk adults while encouraging follow-through. This method bundles upfront price discounts with commitment deposit contracts for hypertensive patients.
Offer patients bundled commitment contracts that combine upfront discount coupons with prepaid consultation fees and deposit options for scheduled doctor visits.
- Enumerators visit target households and offer eligible hypertensive adults a contract bundling three half-price doctor consultation coupons.
- Enumerators require patients to prepay consultation fees upfront at Rs. 15 per visit for three scheduled visits over six months.
- Enumerators offer either a fixed additional commitment deposit of Rs. 45 or a personalized commitment deposit amount chosen by the patient starting at Rs. 0.
- Health workers make follow-up home visits 3 to 4 days later to remind participants about the bundled contract offer and health camp schedules.
- Clinic staff reimburse one-third of the committed deposit amount to the patient at each completed bi-monthly health camp visit.
- Clinic staff retain any unreturned deposit funds if the patient fails to complete the scheduled visits within six months.
Example
In four rural villages in Punjab, India, enumerators offered 572 hypertensive and high-risk respondents bundled subsidized commitment contracts, achieving take-up rates of 25.7% for fixed contracts and 38.7% for personalized contracts, but actual attendance reached only 12.5% to 14.3% of recommended visits.
About the study
Participants
572 enrolled hypertensive and high-risk respondents (280 offered fixed subsidized contracts and 292 offered personalized subsidized contracts) across 4 rural villages in Punjab, India (59% female, average age 53.7 years).
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial arms evaluating fixed and personalized commitment contracts bundled with 3 discount coupons for 50% off consultation fees (Rs. 15 per visit), requiring upfront payment for 3 bi-monthly visits over 6 months.
Results
Contract take-up was 25.7% for fixed subsidized contracts and 38.7% for personalized subsidized contracts; doctor attendance reached 12.5% of recommended visits in fixed subsidized contracts and 14.3% in personalized subsidized contracts, with 62% to 77% of purchasers making zero visits and forfeiting their money.