Allowing patients to choose their commitment level provides flexibility to tailor financial incentives to their perceived self-control needs without imposing a fixed, overly burdening fee structure.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research steps

Describe the chosen deposit contract

  1. Prepay Rs. 90 for three consultations
  2. Choose deposit from Rs. 0; round to thirds
  3. Refund one-third per completed visit

Illustrative summary of the described personalised six-month contract with visits every two months. Unreturned funds are retained after six months. Over 80% of buyers chose zero additional deposit; attendance without discount was 6.6% of recommended visits.

See source →

How

When to use

When at-risk individuals suffer from present bias, standard fixed commitment contracts may feel overly restrictive or rigid. Health providers need a customizable mechanism that lets patients select their own financial commitment level to encourage doctor visits. This method enables hypertensive adults to choose a personalized upfront deposit amount to motivate regular clinic attendance.

Allow patients to select their own upfront deposit commitment amount beginning as low as zero rupees when paying for future preventive doctor visits.

  1. Enumerators offer hypertensive or high-risk respondents a personalized commitment contract for three bi-monthly health camp visits over six months.
  2. Enumerators require respondents to pay Rs. 90 in advance to cover consultation fees for all three visits.
  3. Enumerators allow respondents to choose an additional personalized commitment deposit amount starting at Rs. 0.
  4. Staff round the chosen commitment amount up or down so that it is evenly divisible by 3.
  5. Clinic staff return one-third of the chosen deposit amount to the patient upon completion of each scheduled doctor visit.
  6. Clinic staff retain any unreturned deposit funds if the patient fails to complete the visits within six months.

Example

In four rural villages in Punjab, India, enumerators offered 283 hypertensive and high-risk respondents a personalized contract, resulting in 14.1% take-up without a subsidy, but over 80% of buyers chose a zero deposit amount (m = 0) and completed only 6.6% of recommended visits.

About the study

Participants

283 enrolled hypertensive and high-risk respondents offered the personalized contract without discount (and 292 offered with discount) across 4 rural villages in Punjab, India (59% female, average age 53.7 years).

Study Design

Randomized controlled trial evaluating personalized commitment contracts requiring Rs. 90 upfront consultation fees plus a user-selected deposit amount (m >= Rs. 0), returned in 3 equal installments upon completing doctor visits over 6 months.

Results

Contract take-up was 14.1% without discount and 38.7% with a 50% price discount; over 80% of purchasers selected Rs. 0 additional commitment; clinic attendance was 6.6% of recommended visits without discount and 14.3% with discount, with 62% to 77% of purchasers failing to make a single visit.

Source

See source →