Research steps
Estimate net apprentice work value
- Survey days worked and estimated daily casual-worker replacement cost
- Multiply cost by days; total firm-paid cash and in-kind compensation
- Subtract compensation from gross work value
Illustrative summary of the source-described employer calculation for the prior month. Replacement cost is the employer’s estimate for the same tasks. Net value is not a direct measure of every training or supervision cost; no new estimate is shown.
See source →How
When to use
Small enterprise owners often hesitate to participate in vocational training programs without understanding whether hosting trainees will be financially beneficial. Program evaluators need to determine whether apprentices generate a net economic surplus for host firms. Comparing the market cost of replacing apprentice output with casual labor against total employer compensation reveals the net financial return to host enterprises.
Compute the net employer benefit of hosting apprentices by subtracting the firm's total apprentice compensation bill from the estimated market replacement cost of casual labor.
- Survey host enterprise owners to log daily attendance and work hours for every apprentice present in the firm during the prior month.
- Ask employers to estimate the daily cost they would have incurred to hire an occasional casual worker to accomplish the exact same tasks performed by each apprentice.
- Multiply the daily replacement cost by the number of working days in the month to calculate the gross monthly value of work performed per apprentice.
- Itemize all monetary and in-kind compensation paid by the firm to each apprentice, including direct allowances for transportation, food, clothing, and motivational bonuses.
- Subtract total enterprise apprentice compensation from the gross work value at the firm level to compute the net value of apprentice work.
Why it works
Subtracting enterprise compensation isolates whether host firms capture a net labor surplus that offsets the supervisory time invested in training.
Example
Evaluators in Côte d'Ivoire measured apprentice work value across 674 informal microenterprises, finding that host firms generated an additional 32,115 FCFA per month in gross work value while apprentice compensation rose by only 4,391 FCFA, producing a net value increase of 21,380 FCFA per month per enterprise.
About the study
Participants
674 informal micro and small enterprises evaluated at midline (average 6.4 permanent workers, 84 percent without legal status) across 7 urban localities in Côte d'Ivoire.
Study Design
Enterprise-level randomized controlled trial comparing gross work replacement value and total apprentice wage bills between 361 treatment firms and 370 control firms.
Results
Subsidized apprenticeships increased the monthly value of apprentice work by 32,115 FCFA (p < 0.01) while the employer wage bill increased by a non-significant 4,391 FCFA (p = 0.177), resulting in a statistically significant increase in the net value of work of 21,380 FCFA per month (p = 0.0003), more than doubling the control mean of 19,230 FCFA.