Providing general procedural awareness tests whether reminding litigants of conciliation services encourages dispute resolution without altering case-specific expectations.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research procedure

Test general conciliation information

  1. Select notified hearing cases
  2. Distribute waiting-area leaflets
  3. Compare same-day settlements

Illustrative summary of the source-described placebo trial in Mexico City’s Subcourt 7. Compare two weeks of daily leaflets with two adjacent control weeks. The leaflet had no statistically significant settlement effect.

See source →

How

When to use

Disputing parties in court hearings may fail to settle simply because they are unaware of available court conciliation services or how to access them. Distributing simple promotional leaflets reminding litigants about free, fast, and confidential conciliation tests whether mere service awareness—without case-specific statistical predictions—increases settlement rates.

Distribute promotional conciliation leaflets to disputing parties during court hearing waiting periods to raise awareness of court conciliators.

  1. Prepare single-page promotional leaflets highlighting that conciliation in the court is fast, free, confidential, and impartial.
  2. Identify cases with scheduled hearings where both parties have been formally notified.
  3. Hand out the promotional leaflet to litigants and legal representatives in the court waiting area prior to their hearing.
  4. Direct interested parties who request assistance to the physical location of the subcourt conciliators.

Why it works

The source shows that general service awareness alone does not change settlement behavior, demonstrating that case-specific quantitative predictions are required.

Example

In Subcourt 7 of the Mexico City Labor Court, research enumerators distributed promotional conciliation leaflets to litigants in ongoing cases during scheduled hearing windows. The leaflet intervention produced no statistically significant change in same-day settlement rates compared to the control group.

About the study

Participants

Litigants and legal representatives in ongoing labor court cases scheduled Monday through Thursday in Subcourt 7 of the Mexico City Labor Court.

Study Design

Randomized placebo trial conducted at the bi-weekly level, comparing two weeks of daily conciliation leaflet distribution against two adjacent control weeks without intervention.

Results

The placebo leaflet treatment had no statistically significant effect on same-day settlement rates, yielding a coefficient of -0.011 compared to the control group mean of 7.2 percent.

Source

See source →