Research procedure
Provide information before a lawsuit
- Survey workers before legal counsel
- Calculate and explain predictions
- Follow up at 2 weeks and 2 months
Illustrative summary of the source-described pre-suit procedure in Mexico City. Collect job details, print salary-day settlement ranges and historical zero-payment probability, then give a five-minute explanation. Follow-ups record settlement and financial well-being.
See source →How
When to use
Dismissed workers seeking legal options often hold unrealistic expectations about lawsuit payouts before hiring an attorney. Providing information at this pre-suit stage corrects worker overconfidence before contract formation with private lawyers, preventing long delays and unviable litigation.
Provide personalized statistical predictions of lawsuit outcomes to recently dismissed workers before they retain a lawyer or file a court claim.
- Approach recently dismissed workers who arrive at the court seeking information prior to contracting with legal counsel.
- Conduct an intake survey collecting employment characteristics, including wage, tenure, weekly working hours, and industry.
- Input the worker's job data into the statistical prediction calculator calibrated on historical concluded court cases.
- Print a customized information sheet displaying expected settlement ranges expressed as days of salary and the historical probability of receiving zero payment at trial.
- Have trained enumerators review the prediction sheet with the worker in a 5-minute explanation.
- Conduct telephone follow-ups at 2 weeks and 2 months to record pre-suit settlement decisions and financial well-being.
Why it works
Bypassing private attorneys eliminates agency frictions where fee-seeking lawyers encourage unviable lawsuits or fail to pass along realistic settlement prospects.
Example
In Phase 3 at the Mexico City Labor Court between May 2017 and August 2018, research enumerators provided statistical outcome predictions to 925 recently dismissed workers at an information booth. Pre-suit settlement rates measured two months later increased by 6.4 percentage points compared to the control group.
About the study
Participants
1,929 recently dismissed workers approaching the Mexico City Labor Court before retaining a lawyer (925 treated, 1,004 control), where 45 percent were female with an average daily wage of 323 pesos and tenure of 3.71 years.
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial assigning days across a 15-month experimental window to deliver personalized prediction sheets at a court information booth or standard unassisted consultation.
Results
The treatment increased pre-suit settlement rates by 6.4 percentage points from a 38.7 percent control mean two months after initial contact, while reducing reported rates of missing basic service payments by 7.0 percentage points and lacking food money by 6.7 percentage points.