Try, learn and adjust
Check flat credits follow recorded visits
- Plan: Explain Meena’s assigned fixed phone-credit reward for each vaccination visit.
- Try: Record the completed vaccine on the tablet linked to Meena’s phone. Transfer the fixed credit.
- Learn: Compare the recorded visit and phone credit: did the correct fixed reward arrive?
- Adjust: Keep matching transfers next visit. Change processing where recorded visits did not receive the assigned reward.
Illustrative: Meena is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested, untested loop. Observe visit records and fixed credits. Flat incentives had no impact on full immunization in the reported combinations.
How
When to use
Caregivers in low-income settings often fail to complete full vaccination schedules for their children. Fixed monetary transfers can help offset the immediate time and transport costs of attending health clinics. Deploy this method to offer a constant financial credit per clinic visit to encourage regular immunization attendance.
Offer a constant amount of mobile phone credit to caregivers each time they present a child for vaccination.
- Health clinic managers establish a fixed credit reward amount for each required child immunization visit.
- Nurses and local health workers display informational posters and verbally inform parents about the flat credit reward.
- Caregivers bring their infants to monthly village health sessions to receive scheduled vaccine doses.
- Auxiliary nurse midwives record each completed vaccination on a clinic tablet platform tied to the caregiver's phone number.
- Automated software transfers the fixed phone credit amount to the caregiver's mobile phone account after each verified visit.
Why it works
However, because the reward amount remains constant, it fails to motivate caregivers to complete later vaccination visits.
Example
In Haryana, India, researchers evaluated flat incentives offering either 50 rupees per visit (250 rupees total) or INR 90 per visit across five child vaccine doses.
About the study
Participants
Caregivers of children under twelve months of age across 70 primary health centers in Haryana, India.
Study Design
A randomized controlled trial evaluating flat mobile phone credits against control groups and alternative incentive schedules across 75 cross-randomized policy packages.
Results
Flat incentives across the immunization schedule produced no impact on child full immunization rates in any policy combination.