Providing half the asset value and coaching still breaks liquidity constraints and imparts essential skills.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Try, learn and adjust

Check the half-cost bundle retains its support

  1. Plan: Arrange productive assets worth EGP 5,500 and half the standard coaching and savings meeting frequency for Mariam’s household.
  2. Try: Provide technical and financial training and service links. Pay EGP 400 monthly for eight months if not receiving government cash transfers.
  3. Learn: Check asset receipt, training, reduced-frequency meetings and eligible cash support.
  4. Adjust: Keep delivery checks for future households if complete. Otherwise resolve missing support within the half-cost design.

Illustrative: Mariam is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.

See source →

School’s suggested, untested loop: observe the whole half-cost bundle without changing its tested asset value or contact frequency.

How

When to use

Governments and development organisations often face budget constraints that prevent them from scaling expensive full-cost graduation packages. This reduced-intensity model provides a lower-cost alternative to improve living standards for ultra-poor households. It applies to poverty alleviation programs in rural areas with limited funding.

Implement a lower-cost graduation bundle by halving asset values and contact frequency while retaining core support components.

  1. Target ultra-poor households in rural villages of Upper Egypt.
  2. Transfer productive assets worth EGP 5,500 per household, halving the standard asset transfer value.
  3. Provide financial and technical skills training relevant to the selected enterprise.
  4. Distribute EGP 400 in monthly consumption support for 8 months to eligible households not receiving government cash transfers.
  5. Reduce coaching home visits and savings group meetings to half the standard program frequency.
  6. Connect participants to government social services and local solidarity committees.

Why it works

The source notes that a less intensive program can still help households achieve lasting gains at a lower cost per beneficiary.

Example

In Assiut and Sohag governorates, ultra-poor households received the half-cost graduation variant. Total livestock wealth in this group increased to EGP 6,858 at midline and EGP 9,493 at 40-month endline, compared to EGP 3,350 in the control group.

About the study

Participants

3,465 ultra-poor households in rural villages of Assiut and Sohag governorates, Upper Egypt.

Study Design

Randomized controlled trial comparing half-cost, full-cost unrestricted, full-cost restricted, and control groups over 20-month midline and 40-month endline follow-ups.

Results

Total livestock value reached EGP 6,858 at midline and EGP 9,493 at endline compared to EGP 3,350 in control; total monthly expenditure reached EGP 4,448 at endline versus EGP 4,272 in control; total monthly income reached EGP 3,083 at endline versus EGP 2,794 in control; female empowerment index increased by 0.05 standard deviations.

Source

See source →