Try, learn and adjust
Check village selection of seed recipients
- Plan: Ravi, an NGO worker, brings 25 kilograms of seed in five-kilogram packets in May.
- Try: Explain the variety at an open meeting; villagers choose recipients to plant from June.
- Learn: Check recipient choices and planting: did villagers jointly choose who received the packets?
- Adjust: Keep joint selection checks next distribution if recorded. Otherwise change how meeting decisions are recorded.
Illustrative: Ravi is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested, untested learning loop. Observe community selection and wet-season planting; this loop does not establish later adoption effects.
How
When to use
Smallholder farmers need resilient crop varieties, but selecting early demonstrators through political leaders risks favoritism. Program managers need a community-driven selection method to pick early adopters fairly. This approach uses open village meetings where community members collectively decide who receives trial seed packets.
Distribute trial seed packets through open, participatory village meetings to let community members select early adopters.
- NGO staff visit target villages in May carrying 25 kilograms of a new seed variety divided into five-kilogram packets.
- NGO staff inform villagers about a short meeting focused on new crop varieties.
- NGO staff present the seed packets during the meeting and describe the variety's benefits over traditional seeds.
- Villagers jointly decide who receives the seed packets to cultivate the new variety.
- Selected early adopters plant the seeds during the wet season starting in June.
Why it works
Peer-selected early adopters share information effectively, leading to identical downstream technology adoption compared to official-selected demonstrators.
Example
In 34 flood-prone villages in Odisha, India, NGO staff held village meetings in May 2014 to present five-kilogram packets of flood-tolerant Swarna-Sub1 rice seed. Villagers jointly decided who would cultivate the seeds during the wet season. This participatory process reduced official favoritism in early adopter selection without reducing peer learning or seed adoption in the next planting season.
About the study
Participants
34 villages in Odisha, India; rice farmers where two-thirds lived below the US\$2.15/day poverty line and one-third belonged to scheduled castes.
Study Design
Randomized evaluation where 34 out of 100 villages were assigned to seed distribution through participatory village meetings.
Results
Participatory village meetings reduced official favoritism in selecting early adopters, while subsequent peer seed adoption rates remained identical to villages using official or self-help group selection.