Direct patient and provider surveys generate independent, verified clinical data without relying on incomplete facility records.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research groups

Survey providers and mothers after one year

About one year after contracts: 135 providers and 2,895 recent mothers

38 input-contract providers
Survey clinical inputs and patient outcomes.
53 output-contract providers
Survey clinical inputs and patient outcomes.
44 comparison providers
Survey clinical inputs and patient outcomes.

Illustrative summary of the source-described endline evaluation in Karnataka. Provider surveys also measured personality. Branches show contract groups surveyed in the same evaluation period, not a sequence; no results are shown.

See source →

How

When to use

Evaluating health performance incentives requires measuring both clinician behaviors and clinical patient outcomes. Routine administrative records in low-resource settings often lack accurate health output and input data. Postpartum mother and healthcare provider surveying gathers verified outcome data directly from recent mothers and participating clinicians to assess program impact.

Conduct comprehensive facility and patient surveys approximately one year after contract implementation to measure medical practices and health outcomes.

  1. Field researchers locate mothers who recently gave birth at participating private obstetric clinics across rural Karnataka.
  2. Evaluators survey 2,895 postpartum mothers about medical procedures received and health outcomes experienced during and after delivery.
  3. Field staff survey 135 participating healthcare providers to document clinic medical practices and operational details.
  4. Surveyors administer standardized psychological personality tests during provider surveys to assess conscientiousness and neuroticism.
  5. Analysts aggregate patient and provider survey data to evaluate changes in clinical input usage, postpartum hemorrhage rates, and contract payout eligibility.

Why it works

Combining patient outcome reports with provider personality assessments enables evaluators to attribute health improvements directly to contract incentives and provider characteristics.

Example

About one year after contract signing, researchers surveyed 135 private obstetric care providers and 2,895 mothers who had recently given birth at participating facilities in rural Karnataka, India to evaluate medical practices, health outputs, and personality traits.

About the study

Participants

135 participating private obstetric care providers and 2,895 mothers who had recently given birth across rural Karnataka, India.

Study Design

Survey-based endline evaluation conducted approximately one year post-contract signing across input contract (38 providers), output contract (53 providers), and comparison (44 providers) groups.

Results

Endline survey data revealed that both contract types reduced postpartum hemorrhage by 20 to 23 percent, with an average payout of INR 13,850 for input contracts and INR 56,812 for output contracts.

Source

See source →