Try, learn and adjust
Check private counselling follows its schedule
- Plan: Assign Jean a private personal adviser with no more than 40 clients for a 6-month programme.
- Try: Hold weekly individual meetings on search strategy and applications. Use the 30%, 35%, 35% payment milestones.
- Learn: Check meeting records, applications and placement duration against the counselling schedule and payment milestones.
- Adjust: Keep the schedule if delivered. Otherwise change missed-session arrangements before the next meeting.
Illustrative: Jean is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested learning loop: observe weekly support and payment milestones: enrolment, placement and at least 6 months in work; this check does not establish impact.
How
When to use
Governments extend job search support by contracting service delivery out to private providers. Standard public employment agencies often assign high client caseloads to advisors, reducing individual support for job seekers. Private contracted counseling offers intensive, personalized guidance to help benefit-entitled job seekers return to work quickly.
Outsource intensive job counseling for benefit-entitled job seekers to private placement companies using personal advisors and performance-tiered pricing.
- Contract private companies to provide personal job search advisors for job seekers entering unemployment with at least one year of benefit entitlement.
- Limit each private personal advisor's caseload to a maximum of 40 clients at local employment offices for a six-month program period.
- Conduct individual meetings on a weekly basis to assist participants with job search strategy and application submissions.
- Pay contractors through a three-tiered fee structure consisting of a 30 percent upfront enrollment fee, a 35 percent placement fee upon employment, and a 35 percent fee if the job lasts six months.
Why it works
Performance-based payments tie contractor earnings directly to placement speed and long-term employment duration.
Example
UNEDIC launched a contracted intensive counseling program in 2007 across 216 local public employment offices in four French administrative regions. Private advisors met with up to 40 clients weekly for six months at a cost ranging between €900 and €3,947 per client depending on job placement outcomes.
About the study
Participants
Nearly 44,000 job seekers entering unemployment and entitled to at least one year of benefits across 216 local public employment offices in four French administrative regions.
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial conducted from January to December 2007 tracking administrative and survey data over 12 months across private intensive, public intensive, and public standard comparison groups.
Results
Within six months, the private intensive program increased the probability of finding a job by 22 percent, representing a 4.5 percentage-point increase over the comparison group. It increased the probability of finding a job lasting at least six months by 27 percent, a 5 percentage-point increase. Total net expenses increased by approximately €1,162 per enrolled job seeker without reducing benefit payout days.