Original source
Public or Private? Job Counseling in France (2015)
J-PAL policy briefcase; summary of an evaluation · J-PAL Policy Briefcase
Search for this source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Restructure public procurement contracts to eliminate upfront fixed enrollment fees and adjust conditional placement bonuses to prevent provider cream-skimming and sanction dilution.
"Private firms received a large payment conditional on job placement, so in order to maximize their gains, they may have found it efficient to focus their effort on less employable candidates, relying on the better candidates to find jobs by themselves."
Require cost-effectiveness calculations for outsourced public programs to factor in net benefit payout savings alongside administrative service fees.
"Researchers estimate that the private program increased total net expenses per enrolled job seeker by approximately €1,162. The public intensive program reduced net costs to the government per job seeker slightly, but the difference was not statistically significant."
Evaluate job counseling policy interventions based on 6-month and 12-month job retention rates rather than short-term 30-day placement benchmarks.
"The public intensive program increased the likelihood of finding a job lasting at least six months by the end of the counseling period by 34 percent a 7.2 percentage point increase compared to the counterfactual situation."
Conduct rigorous randomized evaluations comparing private contracted services against public provision before expanding outsourcing agreements for social services.
"Researchers estimate that the private program increased total net expenses per enrolled job seeker by approximately €1,162."
Cap public employment caseworker caseloads at 40 clients and implement mandatory weekly individual job search meetings.
"Within six months, the public intensive program increased the probability of exiting unemployment and finding a job by 50 percent (a 10.2 percentage point increase from a base of 20.7 percent)."
Decouple sanction reporting and compliance auditing from private contractor placement bonus payments by placing compliance oversight under an independent public authority.
"Sanctions to inactive job seekers, including temporary or permanent removal from the unemployment list, were also applied less frequently for candidates enrolled in the private program, which may have had an impact on the candidates' efforts to find jobs."