Evaluating technical proposals before opening financial bids ensures that only qualified organizations with proven management plans are considered.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Try, learn and adjust

Check technical eligibility before opening price bids

  1. Plan: Issue district service requirements and request separate technical and price envelopes.
  2. Try: Sokha’s evaluation committee scores technical proposals, rejects those below threshold, then opens eligible price bids publicly.
  3. Learn: Review bid records: were only technically responsive bids given combined technical and price scores?
  4. Adjust: Keep the staged evaluation in the next tender. Change bid handling where price envelopes were opened before technical clearance.

Illustrative: Sokha is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.

See source →

School’s suggested, untested loop. Observe technical scores, public price opening and combined scores. An award follows the top combined score; not every district necessarily receives a contract.

How

When to use

Governments in developing countries often lack managerial capacity to run rural health districts effectively. Standard procurement risks selecting low-cost contractors that lack technical expertise or capable staff. Use a two-envelope competitive tender to select non-governmental organizations based on combined technical capability and price.

Select management contractors for public health districts using a two-envelope competitive procurement process.

  1. Issue a public request for proposals defining mandatory primary health service targets and district boundaries.
  2. Require bidding organizations to submit separate technical and price envelopes for each targeted district.
  3. Convene an evaluation committee of health officials and independent experts to score technical proposals against explicit criteria.
  4. Disqualify proposals that fail to achieve a pre-specified minimum technical score.
  5. Open the price envelopes of technically responsive bidders in a public session.
  6. Combine technical and price scores using an explicit formula and award the contract to the top-scoring bidder.

Why it works

Combining weighted technical and price scores prevents low-quality low-ball bidders from winning while keeping overall contract costs competitive.

Example

The Cambodian Ministry of Health issued a request for bids in 1998 covering eight rural health districts. Ten bidders representing 14 organizations submitted 16 proposals. The ministry evaluated technical envelopes first, opened price envelopes publicly for passing proposals, and awarded management contracts to international NGOs in five districts where bids met technical and cost standards.

About the study

Participants

12 rural districts across Takeo, Prey Veng, and Kampong Cham provinces in Cambodia, covering 1.26 million residents across 360 sample villages with 3,700 households and 143 health centers.

Study Design

Cluster-randomized trial evaluating 12 districts randomly assigned to contracting out, contracting in, or comparison status, using initial random eligibility as an instrumental variable for actual contract rollout.

Results

Ten bidders submitted 16 proposals for eight randomized districts, five districts received technically responsive and cost-effective bids that led to successful management contracts, two districts received bids that failed technical thresholds, and one district received bids judged too expensive.

Source

See source →