Local ecosystem experts effectively filter out low-quality proposals using standardized criteria.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research steps

Screen proposals before investor review

  1. 15 regional professionals score proposals from 1 to 5
  2. Advance scores of 4 or 5; add academic-panel selections
  3. 24 senior investors grade plans and track funding follow-up

Illustrative summary of the source-described procedure. Expert screening precedes investor evaluation. Regional professionals score all submitted proposals; the academic panel adds top-graded plans before investors review the combined pool.

See source →

How

When to use

Organizations need to evaluate a large volume of business proposals from early-stage entrepreneurs. Relying solely on senior venture capitalists to review thousands of raw applications is inefficient. A two-stage evaluation framework uses regional ecosystem experts to screen applications before passing top proposals to venture capitalists for investment decisions.

Evaluate business proposals through a two-stage screening process combining regional ecosystem experts and senior investors.

  1. Collect online business proposals submitted by participants at the conclusion of a training program.
  2. Assign submitted proposals to a panel of 15 regional professional evaluators to score each plan on a 1-to-5 quality scale.
  3. Select proposals receiving top quality scores of 4 or 5 for advancement to the second stage.
  4. Supplement the selected pool with additional top-graded proposals evaluated independently by an academic panel.
  5. Distribute the combined top proposal pool to a panel of 24 senior venture capitalists and angel investors based on sector expertise.
  6. Collect investor quality grades and track follow-up contacts with entrepreneurs for concrete funding decisions.

Why it works

Senior investors can then focus their attention on a pre-screened pool of viable ventures that match their investment preferences.

Example

Program coordinators evaluated 1952 business proposals submitted by African entrepreneurs following a ten-week training program. A panel of 15 African professionals graded all proposals, advancing 444 top-ranked plans to a panel of 24 senior investors who conducted concrete follow-ups on 93 projects and funded up to 30 ventures.

About the study

Participants

1952 business proposals submitted by entrepreneurs across 49 African countries; evaluated by 15 African professionals, 15 PhD evaluators, and 24 senior investors.

Study Design

Two-stage evaluation procedure scoring submitted proposals on a 1–5 scale in Stage 1, advancing top-scoring proposals to Stage 2 for investor grading and funding consideration.

Results

Stage 1 evaluated all submitted proposals on a 1-5 scale, yielding average quality scores of 2.70 in large countries and 2.65 in small countries. Stage 2 evaluated 454 top proposals, leading to concrete investor follow-up for 93 projects and funding or active continuation for up to 30 proposals.

Source

See source →