Farmers facing liquidity constraints spend unrestricted cash on valuable farm equipment rentals just as they would with tied vouchers.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research subsidy design

Compare vouchers with a cash component

Equipment rental support for smallholders

Full rental subsidy
Support tied to equipment rental.
Part delivered as cash
Farmer chooses how to spend cash.

Illustrative summary of the source design: The source compares full rental subsidies with part delivered as unrestricted cash, listing INR 2,100 or INR 3,500 grants. It reports no difference in rental adoption or hours.

See source →

How

When to use

Policy makers often debate whether agricultural assistance should be provided as restricted vouchers or unrestricted cash transfers to smallholder farmers. Restricted subsidies are thought necessary to prevent funds from being spent on non-farm items. Combining or replacing tied rental vouchers with equivalent unrestricted cash grants tests whether cash flexibility alters farm machinery adoption.

Provide farmers with unrestricted cash grants alongside tied equipment rental vouchers to give them financial flexibility during the agricultural season.

  1. Identify small-scale farming households preparing for seasonal land preparation in target agricultural districts.
  2. Issue restricted equipment vouchers worth approximately two hours of machine rental services to participating farmers.
  3. Offer a targeted sub-group an equivalent cash grant of either INR 2,100 (US$23.23) or INR 3,500 (US$38.71) delivered directly to the farmer.
  4. Allow farmers complete discretion to allocate the cash transfer toward agricultural machinery rentals or other household expenditures.
  5. Track equipment rental rates and overall machinery usage across the season to compare cash against tied subsidies.

Why it works

Delivering cash does not lower equipment rental adoption because machinery remains a high-priority agricultural investment.

Example

In Karnataka, India, researchers offered a sub-group of smallholder farmers an equivalent cash grant of either INR 2,100 (US$23.23) or INR 3,500 (US$38.71) alongside equipment rental vouchers. Farmers receiving cash showed no difference in equipment rental rates or total hours rented compared to those receiving the full subsidy as a rental voucher.

About the study

Participants

7,100 small-scale farmers across 190 villages in eight districts of Karnataka, India, with 5,500 completing the endline phone survey.

Study Design

Randomized controlled trial comparing tied equipment rental vouchers against partial cash grant equivalents across low-intensity and high-intensity village groups.

Results

Delivering part of the voucher as cash resulted in no difference in machinery rental adoption or total hours rented relative to delivering the full amount as a rental subsidy.

Source

See source →