Try, learn and adjust
Check the five-day payment threshold
- Plan: Give Meena a pedometer and explain the 10,000-step daily target.
- Try: Collect evening step reports. Pay INR20 (US$0.33) per target day only if at least five days qualify that week.
- Learn: Count qualifying days in the seven-day week: does the payment follow the threshold rule?
- Adjust: Keep the threshold checks next week if accurate; otherwise correct payment recording without changing the assigned contract.
Illustrative: Meena is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested, untested learning loop. Observe daily steps, threshold attainment and weekly payments; no health effect is assumed.
How
When to use
Many impatient adults with diabetes procrastinate exercising because walking carries immediate effort costs while health rewards arrive later. Standard incentive contracts allow individuals to skip days without forfeiting rewards earned on other days. Requiring participants to hit a daily step goal on at least five days per week before receiving payouts bundles present and future effort to motivate impatient participants.
Provide financial rewards that unlock only if participants achieve a daily step goal on a minimum threshold of five days each week.
- Distribute pedometers to program participants to measure daily walking activity.
- Set a daily physical activity goal of 10,000 steps for each participant.
- Require participants to log and report their step counts every evening using an automated system.
- Track whether participants achieve the 10,000-step target on at least five days during the seven-day weekly cycle.
- Pay INR20 (US$0.33) per target day at the end of the week only if the five-day threshold is met, withholding payments if participants fall short.
Why it works
Missing a goal on any given day risks forfeiting rewards for the entire week, which overcomes immediate procrastination for impatient individuals and reduces overall program payout costs.
Example
In Coimbatore, India, diabetic and prediabetic participants in a five-day threshold group received INR20 (US$0.33) per day walked only if they achieved 10,000 steps on at least five days in a given week, achieving a 51 percent target compliance rate over twelve weeks.
About the study
Participants
3,192 adults in Coimbatore, India, averaging 49 years old, where 67 percent had doctor-diagnosed diabetes, 82 percent had elevated HbA1c, 49 percent had hypertension, and 61 percent had obesity.
Study Design
A randomized controlled trial evaluating physical activity incentives and step-monitoring contracts among recruited adults across eight intervention and comparison groups over twelve weeks.
Results
The five-day threshold contract achieved a 51 percent target compliance rate, while overall threshold contracts increased target completion by 6 percentage points for impatient individuals relative to patient individuals and reduced program payout costs by 10 to 15 percent without reducing steps walked.