Source · aikyam school

Addressing High School Dropouts with a Scalable Intervention: The Case of PODER

Original source

Ciro Avitabile; Janina Cuevas; Rafael de Hoyos; Julian C. Jamison

Addressing High School Dropouts with a Scalable Intervention: The Case of PODER

Working paper · World Bank, Education Global Practice · Policy Research Working Paper 9085 · Version date: December 2019

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Deploy automated screening algorithms using baseline administrative GPA and entrance examination scores to identify and rank the top 20% most vulnerable incoming high school students prior to academic year orientation.

"Once we condition on school fixed effects, GPA and the COMIPEMS admission exams could explain 19% of the total variation in the probability of completing, on-time, upper secondary."

Implement a master-clinician-to-teacher cascade training model using standardized instruction handbooks to scale socio-emotional workshops within public school networks.

"UNAM psychologists then delivered between 25 and 35 hours of training, depending on the treatment arm, including CBT and 'youth engagement' to volunteer teachers between September 5 and October 7."

Incorporate active attendance tracking and minimum participation milestones of at least 5 sessions when implementing voluntary socio-emotional programs.

"For students attending 5 or more CBT sessions, the probability of enrolling in 11th grade increases by 19 percentage points."

Select psychometric evaluation instruments that measure the explicit sub-skills targeted by an intervention rather than relying on broad emotional intelligence inventories.

"The effect on the PLANEA score is large and statistically significant, about 0.17 and 0.18 standard deviations (sd)... When we look at the impact on the BarOn inventory, we find an effect that is small for both treatment groups and statistically not significant."

Replace rigid semester-repetition requirements with targeted course-level leveling and credit-recovery mechanisms to prevent early subject failures from triggering full school disengagement.

"According to the 2009 Survey of EMS Dropouts... subject repetition is the second most common reason after financial constraints-mentioned as a reason for early dropout."

Integrate socio-emotional skills support into the standard core curriculum during regular school hours rather than offering voluntary out-of-school targeted pull-out sessions.

"Lack of information about the program's objective and limited familiarity with counselling and psychological support were quickly filled by stigma, labeling PODER as a program to help 'problem students'."

Identify regional low-skill job growth spikes and implement targeted retention subsidies or flexible work-study schedules for 16-year-old high school students.

"In particular, Atkin (2016) finds that the export manufacturing boom that Mexico experienced in the 1990s generated an abundance of new low-skill formal job opportunities which substantially raised the probability of quitting for youths on the dropout margin at age 16."

Reallocate financial resources from broad secondary student scholarships toward targeted academic remediation and structural dropout prevention.

"Dustan (2018) and de Hoyos, Attanasio and Meghir (2019) provide rigorous evidence that two scholarship programs - 'PROBEMS' and 'Prepa Si' - had, on average, a precisely estimated null effect on proxies for high school graduation."

Embed voluntary socio-emotional and academic support programs directly within compulsory school timetable hours to eliminate attendance friction for working students.

"The CBT workshops and math tutoring were planned to be held during out-of-school hours. This was particularly challenging for students who had to arrive earlier at school or stay later... since many of the students... combine school with work."

Structure remedial math instruction around students' sociocultural contexts and embed sessions within mandatory school timetables.

"The math training for tutors is based on the social epistemological theory which has a paradigm that rests on the use of contexts accounting for social and cultural characteristics of the students to build meaningful mathematical knowledge."

Distinguish permanent educational dropouts from strategic exam re-applicants when measuring program success in centralized upper secondary assignment systems.

"Some students not enrolling in 11th grade might do so to re-enroll in the centralized assignment system, COMIPEMS, to have a chance of getting a place in an academic option that is either more selective or more aligned with their preferences."

Train existing teaching staff in standardized cognitive behavioral therapy modules and student engagement techniques to deploy scalable socio-emotional workshops across public school networks.

"Rather than using counselors who arrived with a background and expertise in psychology or social work, which would never have been possible to implement across a significant number of upper secondary schools in Mexico, the PODER program used existing teaching staff."

Precede structured cognitive behavioral therapy sessions with dedicated trust-building and group dynamic exercises to establish psychological safety for adolescent participants.

"The socio-emotional intervention was designed by the Faculty of Psychology at the 'Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México' (UNAM) and it combines conventional cognitive behavioral therapy with 'youth engagement' strategies."