Research procedure
Build balance-matched odds-prize cells
- Select single-prize winners from the same draw
- Match account balances within narrow intervals
- Reassign matched winners; retain qualifying cells
Illustrative summary of the source-described odds-prize matching. Match a single odds-prize winner to single fixed- or odds-prize winners. Move matched fixed-prize winners from old cells; exclude cells with winnings below 100,000 SEK.
See source →How
When to use
Researchers need to isolate exogenous wealth shocks among winners of account-balance-dependent lottery prizes in prize-linked savings programs. Account balances directly increase odds-prize amounts, creating endogeneity between winner wealth and unobserved labor preferences. Matching odds-prize winners to other prize winners with similar account balances eliminates balance-driven selection bias.
Construct comparison cells by matching single odds-prize winners to single prize winners in the same monthly drawing who hold similar account balances.
- Identify account holders who won exactly one odds prize in a specific monthly draw during the microfiche observation period.
- Select account holders in the exact same monthly draw who won exactly one prize of either fixed or odds type.
- Measure account balances of all eligible winners in that draw using microfiche administrative records.
- Group each odds-prize winner with winning account holders whose account balances fall within an identical narrow balance interval.
- Reassign matched fixed-prize winners from their original fixed-prize cells to the newly created odds-prize cell.
- Exclude odds-prize cells where total winnings fall below 100,000 SEK to maintain manageable cell volume.
- Assign cell fixed effects to control for account balance baseline variations in panel regressions.
Example
In December 1990, researchers constructed a matching cell containing one winner of a single odds prize and 19 winners of a single fixed prize who all held account balances between 3,000 SEK and 3,200 SEK in the Vinnarkontot prize-linked savings lottery.
About the study
Participants
1,620 odds-prize cells constructed from Swedish prize-linked savings account holders aged 21 to 64 participating between 1986 and 1994.
Study Design
Panel regression controlling for balance-matched odds-prize cell fixed effects to measure five-year labor earnings responses to randomized wealth shocks.
Results
Winning a lottery prize reduces annual pre-tax labor earnings by 1.066 SEK per 100 SEK won, with wage reductions (-0.964 SEK per 100 SEK) driving the response.