Fixed prize values do not depend on the underlying account balance of the winner.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research procedure

Compare fixed-prize winners within draws

  1. Select winners of at least one fixed prize
  2. Group by draw and identical fixed-prize count
  3. Compare outcomes within cells using panel regressions

Illustrative summary of the source-described fixed-prize matching. Zero-prize account holders are excluded. In December 1990, 1,509 single-fixed-prize winners formed one comparison cell.

See source →

How

When to use

Researchers need to isolate unearned wealth shocks from individual wealth differences among lottery players in savings programs. Account balances alter winning chances, which creates confounding correlations between wealth and economic outcomes. Matching players who win the same number of fixed prizes in a draw isolates exogenous prize variation.

Group account holders into comparison cells based on winning the exact same number of fixed prizes in the exact same monthly drawing.

  1. Identify all savings account holders participating in a given monthly draw.
  2. Select account holders who win at least one fixed prize in that draw.
  3. Group players into a single cell if they won the exact same number of fixed prizes in that specific draw.
  4. Exclude account holders who win zero prizes in that draw.
  5. Assign a cell fixed effect to all account holders grouped within that cell.
  6. Run panel regressions comparing outcome variations across players within the same fixed-prize cell.

Why it works

Comparing players within the same draw and prize count ensures prize amounts remain completely independent of prior wealth.

Example

In December 1990, researchers grouped 1,509 Swedish winners who each won exactly one fixed prize in the Vinnarkontot prize-linked savings draw into a single matching cell.

About the study

Participants

219,274 observations of Swedish prize-linked savings account holders aged 21 to 64 participating between 1986 and 2003.

Study Design

Panel regression controlling for fixed-prize cell fixed effects to estimate the causal impact of exogenous lottery wealth on pre-tax labor earnings.

Results

Winning a lottery prize reduces annual pre-tax labor earnings by approximately 1.066 SEK per 100 SEK won per year, with the reduction staying stable across a ten-year follow-up period.

Source

See source →