Source · aikyam school

The Effect of Wealth on Individual and Household Labor Supply: Evidence from Swedish Lotteries

Original source

David Cesarini; Erik Lindqvist; Matthew J. Notowidigdo; Robert Östling

The Effect of Wealth on Individual and Household Labor Supply: Evidence from Swedish Lotteries

Research manuscript

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Forecast workforce exit rates following financial windfalls by applying minimal extensive-margin participation changes unless workers are immediately adjacent to formal institutional retirement thresholds.

"Figure 2A shows winning the lottery reduces labor force participation by about 2 percentage points per 1M SEK won... We also estimate a small positive, but statistically insignificant, effect of winning the lottery on retirement."

Model unearned wealth shocks as adjustments to working hours within existing employment matches rather than drivers of career re-allocation or inter-firm labor mobility.

"We find no evidence that wealth affects employer, workplace, occupation, industry, or location of work... consistent with the hypothesis that changes in hours worked are likely to account for the bulk of the intensive margin response."

Model workforce reductions following wealth shocks primarily as reductions in contractual working hours rather than abrupt job resignations or career shifts.

"Adjustments of the number of hours worked account for the majority of the overall earnings response."

Calibrate macroeconomic tax revenue and welfare models using a Frisch elasticity between 0.10 and 0.15 rather than higher macroeconomic benchmark values exceeding 0.50.

"The individual-level compensated (Hicksian) elasticity is 0.1, and the intertemporal (Frisch) elasticity is 0.15."

When modeling labor supply responses to lump-sum wealth transfers or tax policies, incorporate an annual pre-tax earnings reduction of approximately 1.1% of total unearned windfall value.

"Winning a lottery prize modestly reduces earnings, with the reduction being immediate, persistent, and quite similar by age, education, and sex."

Treat lump-sum and structured annuity wealth transfers as economically equivalent when forecasting aggregate worker labor supply adjustments over multi-year horizons.

"If winners have a significant bias to the present and Triss-Monthly winners are unable to borrow against their future income stream, we would expect bigger immediate responses from lump-sum prizes. Yet the response patterns for the two Triss lotteries are quite similar."

Apply linear marginal propensity to earn parameters uniformly across both small and large wealth transfer sizes when forecasting labor market responses.

"The point estimates suggest the marginal effect of lottery wealth is smaller for larger prizes, but the difference is not statistically significant."

Exclude unearned cash transfers or lottery windfalls as direct drivers of entrepreneurial expansion or business startup activity when evaluating small business policy interventions.

"The reduction in self-employment income is at odds with previous findings that windfall gains increase self-employment... a 1M SEK windfall gain reduces self-employment income by 7.7 percent of the annual average compared to 5.5 percent for wage earnings."

Design intra-household transfer programs that assign benefits directly to target individuals rather than relying on statutory household-level divorce division laws to equalize intra-household allocation.

"Instead, our results appear to be more consistent with the 'separate spheres' household model of Lundberg and Pollak (1993) that relies on bargaining with threat points internal to the marriage."

Multiply individual-level income effect estimates by a factor of 1.23 to capture total household labor supply reductions when evaluating unearned wealth transfers.

"Including the response of non-winning spouses increases the labor supply response from -1.066 to -1.306. Focusing only on winners thus leads us to an underestimation of the labor supply response by 23 percent."

Model the fiscal footprint of unearned wealth transfers by accounting for employer payroll tax cushions that cause gross economic production losses to exceed individual disposable income losses by over two to one.

"According to our estimate, a 100 SEK windfall is estimated to reduce the total production value by 1.412 SEK per year in the first five post-lottery years... the estimated effect on after-tax income (-0.576) is substantially smaller than the effect on total production value."

Tax registers record annual wage earnings for every employed individual without survey non-response.

Two individuals who purchase the same number of subscription tickets in a given draw face the exact same probability of winning a prize.

Comparing winners with similar account balances in the same drawing holds baseline wealth constant while isolating randomized variation in winning an odds prize versus a fixed prize.

Requiring both spouses to be active lottery participants balances underlying unobserved preferences for gambling, risk, and labor across husbands and wives.

Fixed prize values do not depend on the underlying account balance of the winner.

Matching structural model moments to empirical after-tax earnings trajectories isolates time-preference and income-effect parameters, allowing researchers to extrapolate labor supply responses across remaining working years.

Conditional on qualifying for the televised draw, drawing a specific scratch ticket from the TV show stack yields a completely random prize amount under a fixed prize plan.

Mathematical decomposition of annual wage earnings isolates the exact proportion of labor income reduction caused by working fewer hours versus taking lower hourly wages.