Including in-kind compensation captures non-monetary agricultural and barter output that forms the primary livelihood of rural farmers.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research steps

Value cash and non-cash work

  1. List work over the previous 12 months
  2. Record cash; estimate non-cash work value
  3. Sum values into annual income

Illustrative summary of the source-described procedure. The 2006 Malawi survey asks about cash and in-kind work, including agricultural production. Non-cash amounts are respondents’ estimated monetary values, not observed cash payments.

See source →

How

When to use

Rural households in developing nations engage heavily in subsistence agriculture and barter alongside casual wage labor. Measuring only monetary earnings misses crop production and non-cash compensation, underestimating household economic capacity. Combining cash payments with imputed monetary values for in-kind earnings provides an accurate total annual income measurement.

Calculate annual household income by measuring cash earnings and valuing in-kind compensation and agricultural production across all work activities over the preceding year.

  1. Survey enumerators interview respondents during household follow-up visits.
  2. Enumerators list all productive economic activities, paid wage work, and agricultural tasks undertaken by the respondent during the past twelve months.
  3. Enumerators record all direct cash payments earned from wage labor and enterprise.
  4. Enumerators prompt respondents to estimate the monetary market value of all in-kind goods, crops, and non-cash compensation received for work performed.
  5. Enumerators sum cash earnings and estimated in-kind valuations to construct an aggregated annual income variable.

Why it works

This comprehensive aggregation prevents systematic downward bias when evaluating economic well-being and intervention impacts.

Example

Enumerators interviewed 1,813 rural Malawians during the 2006 follow-up survey to calculate total annual income, combining cash and in-kind work value. Instrumental variable regressions showed that learning HIV-negative test results had no statistically significant effect on log income two years later.

About the study

Participants

1,734 HIV-negative adults in rural Malawi (41 percent male, average age 35 years, 4.9 years of education).

Study Design

Two-stage linear instrumental variables regression (2SLS) evaluating total log annual income across tested individuals, instrumented by randomized incentives and distance costs.

Results

Learning HIV-negative status produced a non-significant point estimate of 0.109 on log annual income (SE 0.194, minimum detectable effect size 0.322).

Source

See source →