Reusing improved cereal seeds beyond four consecutive seasons degrades genetic purity and yield potential.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Survey classification

Classify seed reuse by the stated threshold

Record the original seed source and consecutive reuse seasons

Four or fewer seasons
Count as improved under the survey rule.
More than four seasons
Do not count as improved in the analysis.

Illustrative summary of the source-described seed classification rule in the Ethiopian survey. This shows how reuse history enters the analysis, without projecting adoption results.

See source →

How

When to use

Smallholder farmers routinely recycle and share improved cereal seeds across multiple harvest cycles. Over successive generations, key genetic traits and disease resistance degrade, causing recycled seeds to perform like traditional varieties. Implementing a generational tracking protocol during agricultural surveys prevents overestimating true improved seed adoption rates.

Track cereal seed origins and reuse durations during farm surveys to classify seeds based on genetic quality thresholds.

  1. Administer structured survey questions asking household heads for the original acquisition source of planted crop seeds.
  2. Record the exact number of consecutive cropping seasons the household has re-harvested and replanted the same seed lot.
  3. Apply a four-season threshold rule to determine seed genetic classification.
  4. Categorize seeds reused for four or fewer cropping seasons as genuine improved seeds.
  5. Disqualify seeds reused for more than four seasons from being classified as improved seeds in impact evaluations.

Why it works

Disqualifying older recycled seeds ensures survey metrics reflect true access to productive genetic inputs rather than degraded varieties.

Example

In the endline survey across 2,382 smallholder households in Amhara, Oromia, and Tigray in Ethiopia, enumerators recorded seed origins and recycling years for wheat, maize, teff, barley, and sorghum. Excluding seeds reused past four generations adjusted the measured endline improved seed adoption rates to 57.4 percent in control communities, 63.9 percent under extension alone, and 63.8 percent under extension plus video.

About the study

Participants

N = 2,382 smallholder farming households across 201 microwatersheds in Ethiopia.

Study Design

Survey data verification protocol embedded in a cluster Randomized Controlled Trial to eliminate measurement error in self-reported improved seed adoption.

Results

Following generational verification, assignment to extension alone (T1) increased improved seed adoption by 6.5 percentage points (p = 0.027), while extension plus video (T2) increased adoption by 12.9 percentage points (p = 0.027) relative to the control mean of 57.4 percent.

Source

See source →