Research overview
Compare previous gift sizes
50,083 prior donors; median previous gift $35
- Previous gift below $35
- Analyse response to matching offers among small donors.
- Previous gift above $35
- Analyse response to matching offers among large donors.
Illustrative summary of the source’s donor-size subgroup comparison. Previous gift size is not randomly assigned; no rule for gifts exactly at the median is supplied.
See source →How
When to use
Nonprofit organizations solicit contributions from past donors across varying historical giving levels. Large prior donors often contribute regardless of price incentives, while small prior donors may be more sensitive to price reductions. Segmenting solicitations by past gift size allows organizations to focus matching grant offers where they generate the highest relative participation lift.
Segment direct mail solicitation lists by prior contribution size to direct matching grant incentives toward small donors.
- Extract historical contribution records for all past supporters in the mailing list.
- Calculate the median historical contribution amount across the donor database to establish a threshold between small and large prior donors.
- Classify supporters with a highest previous gift below the median threshold as small prior donors.
- Allocate matching grant direct mail solicitations specifically to the small prior donor segment.
- Send standard, non-matched solicitations to large prior donors whose past gifts exceed the median threshold.
- Measure response rates and total revenue across small and large donor segments to evaluate campaign performance.
Why it works
The matching offer provides the necessary push to encourage smaller supporters to make another gift.
Example
A civil liberties nonprofit in the United States evaluated matching grant direct mail solicitations sent to 50,083 prior donors, dividing them by past contribution size relative to the median gift of $35. The matching grant offer was significantly more effective at increasing contribution probability among small prior donors below the $35 median threshold than among large prior donors above it.
About the study
Participants
50,083 prior donors to a US civil liberties nonprofit, split at the median prior gift threshold of $35.
Study Design
Randomized natural field experiment testing matching grant direct mail letters across prior donor giving strata.
Results
The matching grant offer produced a statistically significant higher increase in response rate for small prior donors below the median gift of $35 compared to large prior donors above the median gift.