Unannounced physical checks prevent health workers from altering their attendance behavior in advance.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research steps

Audit attendance against reported schedules

  1. Record the coming week’s duty schedule
  2. Visit unannounced one week later
  3. Record presence during the reported shift

Illustrative summary of the source-described procedure. The source revisits 94 of 103 providers in Nairobi. Visits check physical presence when providers said they would work; associations with baseline game reciprocity are not randomised attendance effects.

See source →

How

When to use

Public health facilities in developing countries face high worker absence rates that degrade care quality. Standard self-reported schedules fail to give an accurate picture of actual worker attendance. This audit method uses unannounced physical facility visits to measure real-life provider absenteeism directly.

Conduct unannounced follow-up facility visits to measure actual health worker attendance at their assigned work times.

  1. Record each health worker's self-reported work schedule for the upcoming week during an initial survey or workshop session.
  2. Schedule a surprise follow-up audit to the primary facility during a day and time the health worker stated they would be on duty.
  3. Send field enumerators unannounced to the facility exactly one week after recording the schedule.
  4. Verify the physical presence or absence of each targeted health worker on site.
  5. Log attendance outcomes to construct objective facility absenteeism rates.

Why it works

Comparing actual physical presence against scheduled shifts provides an unbiased measure of real-world worker effort.

Example

In Nairobi, Kenya, researchers conducted surprise visits to primary health facilities to audit 94 health providers one week after a community workshop. Field enumerators found 44 percent of sampled health workers absent during their scheduled work shifts across public and private facilities.

About the study

Participants

94 health providers (re-visited out of 103 total participants) from public and private health centers and dispensaries in Nairobi, Kenya.

Study Design

Unannounced follow-up facility audits conducted one week after collecting self-reported duty schedules, comparing recorded physical presence against baseline experimental game reciprocity.

Results

Unannounced visits revealed a 44 percent overall provider absence rate (45 percent in public facilities, 40 percent in private facilities), and high baseline reciprocity in a Trust Game correlated with lower public worker absenteeism (38 percent absent for high-reciprocity workers vs 61 percent for low-reciprocity workers).

Source

See source →