Source · aikyam school

Health Workers’ Behavior, Patient Reporting and Reputational Concerns: Lab-in-the-Field Experimental Evidence from Kenya

Original source

Isaac Mbiti; Danila Serra

Health Workers’ Behavior, Patient Reporting and Reputational Concerns: Lab-in-the-Field Experimental Evidence from Kenya (2018)

IZA discussion paper · IZA Discussion Paper 11352

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Utilize behavioral game exercises during public health workforce screening to identify candidate intrinsic prosociality and mitigate downstream employee absenteeism.

"Across all measures, health workers who are more reciprocal tend to be less absent during our unannounced visits, especially if working in the public sector."

Design citizen reporting channels with complete individual anonymity and external third-party data collection to eliminate social friction and fear of retaliation when reporting local service providers.

"when complaints lead to tangible consequences (either monetary or non-monetary) for providers, patients are less willing to file such complaints, mainly due to the existence of personal relationships with providers."

Establish non-monetary peer accountability channels in public health clinics by displaying aggregated patient satisfaction ratings and complaint counts on internal staff notice boards visible to peer health workers.

"disclosing patients' complaints to providers' professional peers increases providers' pro-social behavior toward patients as much as imposing monetary penalties based on patients' complaints;"

Structurally insulate citizen whistleblowers from provider counter-sanctions by stripping service providers of discretionary punishment authority and concealing patient identities.

"When provider retaliation is allowed, the effectiveness of the Peer Disclosure reporting system, with respect to provider reciprocity, is reduced to between 22 and 25 percentage points relative to the Complaint Box (approximately 21 to 24 percent)."

Separate complaint system metrics into participation rate and grievance severity indicators to accurately interpret citizen feedback data when designing public service oversight mechanisms.

"However, conditional on filing reports, the interventions lead to greater intensity of complaints (measured by the number of cards sent)."

Differentiate healthcare workforce management by deploying reputational peer-review systems in public sector institutions while utilizing financial incentive or penalty structures in private sector clinics.

"public sector health workers are more generous toward patients, and more responsive to the Peer Disclosure mechanism than their private sector counterparts, whose reciprocity is only responsive to the Monetary Penalty system."

Target peer disclosure and reputational oversight mechanisms specifically at chronically underperforming public health facilities rather than imposing universal oversight across all staff.

"less pro-social health workers, as measured in a standard Trust Game, are more responsive to the threat of both peer shaming and monetary sanctions."

Provide legal protections, low-barrier reporting tools, and zero-cost submission mechanisms to prevent socioeconomic bias from suppressing complaint volume among low-income service recipients.

"Focusing on the coefficients of the interaction between wealth and the treatments, we find that wealthier patients (relative to poorer patients) are more likely to complain if reports lead to monetary penalties (MP) than if it leads to no consequences for the providers."

The decision to return money in an anonymous Trust Game reflects intrinsic prosocial motivation.

Direct financial deductions increase the material cost of underperformance for service providers.

Using facility staff rosters and exit interviews creates clear, unbiased sampling frames of actual service providers and active service users.

Health workers care about social observability, peer judgment, and professional reputation among their colleagues.

Allowing provider retaliation increases the expected cost of complaining for patients, lowering their likelihood of reporting.

Private complaint boxes deliver individual feedback directly to service providers without incurring social or financial penalties.

The strategy elicitation method ensures complete comparability across all participating patients by holding the evaluated scenarios constant.

Unannounced physical checks prevent health workers from altering their attendance behavior in advance.