Try, learn and adjust
Check fixed referral rewards match screening
- Plan: Offer Meena Rs. 150 for each referred contact screened, regardless of test results. Issue numbered referral slips.
- Try: Meena distributes slips outside her household within 30 days. Contacts have 30 days from receipt to attend screening; staff log identifiers and pay verified rewards.
- Learn: Compare screening logs with payments: was each verified screening rewarded at Rs. 150 regardless of diagnosis?
- Adjust: Keep the payment checks for future referrals if they match. Otherwise change how screening and payment entries are reconciled.
Illustrative: Meena is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School's suggested, untested loop: observe screening identifiers and fixed payments. This is not a tested clinical protocol.
How
When to use
Current tuberculosis patients face social stigma and time costs when encouraging prospective patients to seek screening. Unconditional financial rewards provide fixed compensation per prospective patient screened regardless of diagnostic outcome. This method motivates current patients to overcome barriers and actively identify symptomatic social contacts.
Offer current tuberculosis patients a fixed financial payment for every referred contact who presents at a clinic for health screening.
- Survey enumerators inform current tuberculosis patients at DOTS centers that they will receive Rs. 150 for each new contact who presents for screening.
- Enumerators issue physical referral cards with unique identification numbers to current patients to hand out to symptomatic social contacts outside their immediate households.
- Current patients locate at-risk peers in their social networks and distribute referral cards within a 30-day window.
- Prospective patients present their cards to counselors at Operation ASHA clinics within 30 days of receipt to undergo screening.
- Clinic counselors log the unique identification number on each card in a referral register upon screening the prospective patient.
- Survey enumerators verify the screening log and pay the referrer the fixed Rs. 150 reward per screened suspect regardless of sputum test results.
Why it works
Because prospective patients' willingness to get screened correlates with having symptoms, referrers naturally target contacts who are likely to test positive even when rewards do not depend on test outcomes.
Example
At Operation ASHA DOTS centers in India, offering current patients Rs. 150 per screened contact generated 0.096 new suspects screened per patient and led to the identification of 0.013 active tuberculosis cases per patient.
About the study
Participants
1,024 current tuberculosis patients at Operation ASHA clinics across 10 cities in India.
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial comparing clinics where referrers were offered Rs. 150 unconditional per screened contact against encouragement-only clinics and conditional incentive clinics.
Results
Unconditional incentives increased referrals to 0.096 screened suspects per patient compared to 0.044 under encouragement alone (p=0.03), yielding 0.057 symptomatics tested and 0.013 active cases identified per patient at \\(US 36 per suspect screened and \\)US 183 per active case detected.