Avoided peak capacity investments represent large capital savings because peaker plants run during very few high-demand hours.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research procedure

Project utility costs and benefits

  1. Estimate avoided capacity and energy costs
  2. Tally setup and recurring costs
  3. Discount benefits minus costs

Illustrative summary of the source’s 10-year cost-benefit simulation for a rollout across 600,000 residential customers. It uses a 7.1% nominal discount rate and adjusts recurring costs for customer attrition. Projections are not realised returns.

See source →

How

When to use

Public electric utilities need to determine whether time-varying rate programs justify their fixed and recurring implementation costs. Deploying dynamic pricing requires substantial upfront billing software updates, marketing outreach, and customer support. Conducting a ten-year net present value cost-benefit analysis compares avoided generation and capacity expenses against program expenditures to guide utility investment decisions.

Calculate ten-year net present value benefits and costs for dynamic pricing programs scaled across a utility customer base.

  1. Financial analysts project avoided generation capacity investment costs by multiplying hourly customer load reductions by the estimated annual cost of peaker plant construction.
  2. Financial analysts project avoided energy generation costs by multiplying hourly customer kilowatt-hour reductions by wholesale energy spot prices.
  3. Administrative staff tally one-time fixed IT billing and program design expenditures.
  4. Marketing staff calculate one-time variable customer acquisition and in-home display provision costs across enrolled households.
  5. Operations staff calculate recurring annual administrative, customer service, and equipment monitoring expenses adjusted for annual customer attrition.
  6. Financial analysts sum total discounted benefits and subtract total discounted costs over a ten-year horizon using a 7.1 percent nominal discount rate.

Why it works

Scaling enrollment through default opt-out mechanisms spreads fixed software and administrative overhead over a massive customer base, driving positive net financial returns.

Example

SMUD evaluated a 10-year scaled rollout across 600,000 residential customers in Sacramento, California, finding that CPP opt-out generated $55.4 million in net benefits and TOU opt-out generated $23.0 million in net benefits, whereas TOU opt-in produced a net loss of -$0.5 million.

About the study

Participants

Projected across 600,000 residential utility customers in Sacramento, California over a 10-year horizon.

Study Design

10-year Net Present Value (NPV) cost-benefit simulation using a 7.1 percent nominal discount rate and 4.5 percent real discount rate.

Results

CPP opt-out yielded $94.2 million in total benefits and $38.8 million in total costs for a $55.4 million net benefit, while TOU opt-in yielded $32.0 million in total benefits and $32.5 million in total costs for a -$0.5 million net loss.

Source

See source →