Try, learn and adjust
Check understanding of supervisor pay
- Plan: Prepare Awa’s script with official worker pay, supervisor pay and the monthly difference.
- Try: A telephone operator reads the standard script to Awa individually.
- Learn: Use the immediate survey check: how does Awa’s understanding compare with official pay?
- Adjust: Keep the script for future calls if understood. Otherwise change its explanation and check understanding again.
Illustrative: Awa is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested learning loop: observe post-disclosure understanding. Performance effects differed under meritocratic and non-meritocratic promotion; accurate beliefs alone do not establish higher productivity.
How
When to use
Frontline public sector workers frequently misestimate supervisory compensation and vertical salary progression. This information gap hides the true financial returns to career advancement in public bureaucracies. Disclosing exact salary levels directly to lower-tier employees establishes accurate expectations regarding supervisor compensation.
Disclose exact monthly salary figures and supervisor pay differentials to frontline public sector employees through direct verbal script readings.
- Determine the official monthly compensation for lower-tier workers and their immediate supervisors.
- Calculate the exact monthly pay gap between frontline positions and supervisory roles.
- Draft a brief verbal script explicitly stating the frontline salary, the supervisory salary, and the exact difference.
- Assign telephone operators to contact frontline health workers individually.
- Read the standardized script directly to each employee over the phone.
- Verify worker understanding through immediate post-disclosure survey checks.
Why it works
Aligning worker expectations with true vertical pay progression allows employees to evaluate accurately the financial returns to career advancement.
Example
In Sierra Leone, phone operators called 2,009 community health workers earning 150,000 SLL per month across 372 health posts. Operators read a script disclosing that peer supervisors earn 250,000 SLL per month, which is 100,000 SLL more per month. In control health posts, operators read a script confirming only the worker's own salary of 150,000 SLL per month.
About the study
Participants
2,009 Community Health Workers earning 150,000 SLL per month across 372 Peripheral Health Units in Sierra Leone.
Study Design
Randomized experiment cross-randomized with promotion meritocracy, evaluating belief updating and performance ten months after reading salary disclosure scripts.
Results
Disclosing supervisor pay reduced the mean absolute difference between perceived and actual supervisor salary from 35,320 SLL in control to 482 SLL in treatment, increasing household health visits by 23% (+1.809 visits) under meritocracy while decreasing visits by 27% (-1.952 visits) under non-meritocracy.