Measuring medical skills and personality traits reveals how provider characteristics modify response to incentive contracts.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research procedure

Measure provider skills and personality

  1. Record degrees and obstetric training
  2. Measure personality at endline
  3. Compare traits and outcomes across contracts

Illustrative summary of the source-described assessment of 135 providers: 38 input contracts, 53 output contracts and 44 comparison providers. Conscientiousness and neuroticism were measured in provider surveys; traits were not randomly assigned.

See source →

How

When to use

Healthcare incentive programs often yield variable results because provider capabilities and psychological characteristics influence how clinicians respond to financial rewards. Program designers need a method to measure medical qualifications and psychological traits to tailor performance contracts effectively. Assessing provider skill levels and personality traits evaluates clinical qualifications alongside conscientiousness and emotional stability to optimize contract selection.

Administer clinical background evaluations and standardized psychological assessments to healthcare providers during program surveys.

  1. Program evaluators record participating clinicians' medical degrees and specialized obstetric training to classify baseline skill levels.
  2. Field researchers administer standardized personality tests to participating healthcare providers during endline provider surveys.
  3. Evaluators measure provider conscientiousness to assess dependability, organizational skills, and perseverance.
  4. Evaluators measure provider neuroticism to gauge anxiety, insecurity, worry, and emotional stability.
  5. Analysts cross-reference measured skill and personality traits against patient health outcomes across contract types to optimize incentive designs.

Why it works

High skill enables providers to implement new delivery strategies, while low conscientiousness and high emotional stability mark clinicians who benefit most from output incentives.

Example

Researchers in rural Karnataka, India surveyed 135 private obstetric care providers, measuring medical degrees, obstetric training, conscientiousness, and neuroticism to evaluate performance under financial reward contracts.

About the study

Participants

135 participating private obstetric care providers and 2,895 surveyed mothers across rural Karnataka, India.

Study Design

Survey-based assessment of medical degrees, obstetric training, conscientiousness, and neuroticism among providers assigned to input contracts (38), output contracts (53), or comparison group (44).

Results

Output incentives reduced PPH by 11 percentage points more among high-skilled providers than less qualified peers, by 13.3 percentage points among providers with lower conscientiousness, and by 13 percentage points among providers with low neuroticism.

Source

See source →