Research design
Compare flat-reward contract options
Flat Menu: choose a daily step target
- 10,000 steps
- 20 INR for meeting the daily target.
- 12,000 steps
- 20 INR for meeting the daily target.
- 14,000 steps
- 20 INR for meeting the daily target.
Illustrative summary of the described Flat Menu. Check understanding, then implement selected targets for Flat Choice participants over 4 weeks. Higher targets require more walking for the same reward; no results shown.
See source →How
When to use
When designing exercise incentive programs, policymakers need to determine whether contract sorting is driven by price discrimination or by nonstandard preferences like pride or commitment demand. Offering a menu of contracts with varied step targets but identical financial rewards tests whether participants select higher targets even when they are financially dominated. This reveals whether incentive-compatibility price differentials are necessary to induce participants with chronic conditions to select higher goals.
Test the mechanism behind participant sorting by offering a choice menu where step target options carry identical flat financial rewards.
- Present participants with a Flat Menu containing three daily step target options of 10,000, 12,000, and 14,000 steps.
- Set the daily payment rate at 20 INR across all three step targets so that higher step targets require more walking for no extra financial reward.
- Administer a choice survey where participants select their preferred contract option from the Flat Menu.
- Verify participant understanding with comprehension questions to ensure choices are not driven by confusion.
- Assign participants in the Flat Choice group to their selected contract target for the four-week program duration.
Why it works
Comparing Flat Menu choices with Base Menu choices reveals whether incentive-compatible payment structures are essential for driving optimal participant sorting.
Example
In Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India, researchers offered 509 adults with diabetes or hypertension a Flat Menu paying 20 INR across 10,000, 12,000, and 14,000 step targets, finding that 68% selected 10,000 steps, 19% selected 12,000 steps, and 13% selected 14,000 steps.
About the study
Participants
509 participants assigned to the Flat Choice group out of 6,882 total enrolled adults aged 30 to 65 (mean age 50, 40% female, 31% diabetic, 32% hypertensive) in urban Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India.
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial evaluating a non-incentive-compatible Flat Menu (10K, 12K, and 14K targets all paying 20 INR daily) relative to the incentive-compatible Base Menu and the Fixed Medium benchmark over a 4-week contract period.
Results
On the Flat Menu, 33% of participants chose financially dominated targets (19% for 12,000 steps and 13% for 14,000 steps), but the Flat Choice group increased daily walking by only 104 steps relative to Fixed Medium (compared to 420 steps for the Base Menu Choice group).