Subjective evaluations reduce contract noise because teachers feel rewards depend on their direct effort rather than external test score shocks.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Try, learn and adjust

Check raises follow agreed performance criteria

  1. Plan: Agree 4 to 10 criteria with Kavita before the year and explain the assigned raise rules.
  2. Try: Observe and give midterm feedback. After twelve months, rank teachers within school and assign raises from 0% to 10%.
  3. Learn: Compare goals, observations and final ratings: do raise decisions use the pre-established criteria?
  4. Adjust: Keep complete appraisal checks for the next annual cycle; change recordkeeping where criteria or evaluations are missing.

Illustrative: Kavita is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.

See source →

School’s suggested, untested learning loop. Observe criteria, feedback, ratings and raises; this loop is separate from the tested compensation contract.

How

When to use

School systems face difficulty motivating teachers when student exam scores fail to capture well-rounded educational effort. Objective test-score incentives often cause narrow test preparation, negative classroom climate, and reduced student socio-emotional growth. Discretionary raises allow managers to evaluate multidimensional performance without forcing teachers to sacrifice non-tested learning goals.

Reward teachers with annual salary raises based on a manager's subjective evaluation of multidimensional performance criteria set at the beginning of the year.

  1. Establish four to ten specific performance criteria per teacher prior to the academic year, covering pedagogy, classroom behavior management, and administrative tasks.
  2. Present the raise contract rules to managers and teachers once per term through human resources presentations and portal communications.
  3. Conduct regular classroom observations during the school year, spending about one third of manager work hours on staff observation and feedback.
  4. Send teachers midterm performance updates halfway through the year to communicate progress and expected raise standings.
  5. Evaluate teacher effort and performance across the pre-established criteria at the end of the twelve-month review cycle.
  6. Rank teachers within each school into percentile tiers and assign annual salary raises ranging from 0% to 10% based on their tournament rank.

Why it works

Discretionary evaluation also lowers distortion by rewarding holistic teaching practices that foster both academic learning and student socio-emotional development.

Example

A private school system in Pakistan implemented manager-discretionary raises from 0% to 10% for core teachers across 234 schools over a twelve-month review cycle. Teachers under subjective raises improved student test scores by 0.086 standard deviations while increasing attendance by nearly 6 days per year and preserving positive classroom climate.

About the study

Participants

6,080 teachers (80% female), 189 managers, and 141,566 student-subject test observations across 234 private schools in Pakistan (grades 4–13).

Study Design

Randomized controlled trial (RCT) comparing flat 5% raises, manager-discretionary subjective performance raises (0–10%), and test-score percentile value-added objective raises (0–10%) in within-school tournaments over an 18-month intervention.

Results

Subjective performance raises increased student test scores by 0.0859 standard deviations (p = 0.022), increased teacher attendance by 5.927 days per year (p = 0.0719), and achieved a 0.05 standard deviation higher student socio-emotional score compared to objective incentives.

Source

See source →