Percentile value-added controls for initial student preparation so teachers face fair comparisons regardless of baseline student background.

Download image · 1200 × 630 PNG

Research procedure

Link raises to comparable learning growth

  1. Assess baseline; rank endline within starting percentile
  2. Average pupil rankings by teacher; rank within school
  3. Allocate raises across five performance categories

Illustrative summary of the source-described objective performance-pay procedure. Raises range from 0% to 10%, with a 5% school average. Baseline assessments cover spring and autumn; endline comparisons use pupils with the same baseline percentile across the school system.

See source →

How

When to use

Schools struggle to motivate teachers and improve student learning outcomes using flat wage increases. Standard credentials fail to predict performance, and flat wages generate no dynamic sorting of high-performing staff. This method aligns salary growth with objective measures of student test score growth across comparable peer classrooms.

Tie annual teacher salary raises to within-school student test score growth rankings using an objective percentile value-added formula.

  1. Administer standardized baseline assessments across core subjects in the spring and fall terms to establish student starting percentiles.
  2. Rank each student's endline test score relative to all students in the school system who began at the same baseline percentile.
  3. Average the resulting student percentile value-added scores across all classes and subjects taught by each teacher.
  4. Rank all core subject teachers within each school into five performance categories based on their average percentile value-added.
  5. Award annual salary raises ranging from 0 percent for the lowest percentile category up to 10 percent for the top percentile category, maintaining a 5 percent school average raise.

Why it works

Within-school tournaments reward relative effort without exposing teachers to system-wide macro shocks.

Example

A private school network in Pakistan assigned 32 schools to an objective percentile value-added performance raise tournament for core teachers in grades 4 to 13. Top-performing teachers in the 91st to 100th percentiles received a 10 percent raise, average performers in the 16th to 60th percentiles received 5 percent, and the lowest performers in the 0 to 2nd percentiles received 0 percent. The objective performance raise increased student test scores by 0.09 standard deviations among teachers who preferred performance contracts.

About the study

Participants

32 schools with 539 teachers and 5,292 students in grades 4 through 13 across Pakistan; teachers averaged 36 years of age, 5.5 years of experience, and 81 percent were female.

Study Design

School-level randomized controlled trial comparing an objective percentile value-added performance raise tournament against a 5 percent flat raise control group over one school year.

Results

Assignment to objective performance pay increased student test scores by 0.09 standard deviations for teachers who chose performance pay at baseline, improved classroom pedagogy by 0.16 standard deviations, and raised student socio-emotional development by 0.12 standard deviations.

Source

See source →