Try, learn and adjust
Check same-country groups exchange feedback
- Plan: Place Amina in a 60-person online chat group whose members are from the same country.
- Try: Allow public and private discussions. Provide 10 feedback tokens every two weeks and collect proposals after ten weeks.
- Learn: Check whether participants exchange helpful feedback and submit their proposals.
- Adjust: Keep facilitation where exchanges occur. Change prompts to address missing feedback at the next contact without changing group composition.
Illustrative: Amina is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested, untested loop: observe peer discussions and proposal submissions; submission does not establish business success.
How
When to use
Organizations need to connect entrepreneurs digitally to boost business proposal completion and idea quality. Distance and travel costs often prevent entrepreneurs from meeting physically across large countries. Creating nationally homogeneous virtual chat groups provides familiarity and mutual encouragement while scaling across online platforms.
Connect entrepreneurs from the same country in customized online chat groups to share feedback and discuss business ideas.
- Partition registered participants into online chat groups of 60 individuals who all belong to the same country.
- Provide an open-source web platform where participants create public or private communication channels.
- Allow participants to initiate bilateral or multilateral discussion threads with group peers.
- Issue 10 digital tokens to each participant every two weeks to award to peers who provide helpful advice.
- Collect final online business proposals from participants at the end of ten weeks.
Why it works
This social support encourages entrepreneurs to stay engaged, refine their plans, and submit completed business proposals.
Example
Program coordinators assigned 1,111 entrepreneurs across Nigeria, Ghana, Kenya, South Africa, and Tanzania to nationally homogeneous virtual groups of 60 members over ten weeks. In the Large-Country Sample, virtual-within interaction increased proposal submission rates from 38% to 41.6% and elevated extensive quality scores by 0.128 points.
About the study
Participants
3,333 entrepreneurs in the Large-Country Sample (1,111 in virtual-within treatment); 31% female, average age 31.26 years, 65% with an existing business, 81% completed university.
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial comparing virtual-within chat networking against virtual-across networking and a pure course control group over ten weeks in five large African nations.
Results
Virtual-within interaction increased proposal submission rates (\\(\beta = 0.036, p < 0.05\\) full sample; \\(\beta = 0.048, p < 0.05\\) M0 completers), extensive quality (\\(\beta = 0.128, p < 0.01\\)), and intensive quality among motivated M0 completers (\\(\beta = 0.138, p < 0.05\\)).